Sunday, April 28, 2024

To Our Children's Children's Children Once More

 This is my occasional confession of my true view of our world and what we might do to steer our ship in a better direction.  I'm sending this to you because you are one of the most important people in my life and I will value any feedback you may have.  I guess I still believe in the concept of democracy enough to hope that we can make the world a better place by sharing our opinions with those we love. I've found this method of email to a blind copy group to be relatively harmless at the worst.  You are free to respond or not.  For the record, some people have responded to my previous emails of this type and the discussions have been respectful and constructive.  For that I am grateful


I have been troubled in recent weeks by some of the statements by our nation's leaders: (Many of the links below are to Twitter.  Please let me know if you don't have a Twitter account and would like to see the linked pages.)
  • Here is Nancy Pelosi claiming in the US Congress that "Vladimir Putin has ordered rape, kidnapping, and murder in front of family members as a weapon of war to demoralize the people of Ukraine".If this is not true, we are reaching medieval anti-semitic levels of absurdity, it seems to me.  I've been looking into the "Putin is Satan" allegations for many years now and have yet to find compelling evidence. Rather, I've found evidence against many of the routine claims.  Who's going to call Nancy Pelosi out on this?  

  • House Speaker Mike Johnson (R-LA): “I regard myself as a wartime Speaker… Former Speaker Newt Gingrich posted a couple days ago ... that this is the hardest challenge that's faced a Speaker probably in the history of the country … comparable to the Civil War, but maybe worse.”
  • A year ago, I wrote a post mocking Lindsay Graham, Friend of Ukraine

    "It was reported last week that fearful of leaks, Ukraine has shared their offensive plans with only a tiny handful of people in the West. Apparently Lindsay Graham was one of them, as a new Politico piece reports with joy that Graham has been given a very thorough ‘deep-dive’ of the full offensive plans, which he calls very ‘impressive’. He further says that the Russians are in for a big surprise and ‘rude awakening’." 

    A year later we know that the intelligence Lindsay received was wrong and it was NATO that received a rude awakening.  This is the story of my life, from Vietnam through Iran, Iraq , and Afghanistan.  Yet we continue to defer to the intelligence experts.
  • And now we have given the intelligence agencies more power:



    But someone I don't know responds: “That is the whole point of laws: to be based upon information accessible to the public and NOT on secret information only available to a select few. That’s how Kings rule and; not how democracies legislate."  [Josh Eisen is his name]
I am for an alternative to what I consider to be our current cancerous national security state.  I believe in the need for national security and intelligence, I believe that many of the people in the system are well-intentioned and intelligent.  But I believe there is a systemic rot that trumps these other beliefs, and this is based on my lifetime of experience.  I share this out of concern for you know, those referenced in the title, as well as for all of us here today.  This includes, especially, the people of Ukraine.

Thursday, March 21, 2024

Dealing with the Loss of Technological Superiority

Dealing with the Loss of Technological Superiority


"The fall of an empire—the end of a polity, a socioeconomic order, a dominant culture, or the intertwined whole—looks more like a cascading series of minor, individually unimportant failures than a dramatic ending that appears out of the blue." Patrick Wyman


  1. Technological superiority naturally diminishes over time as technologies spread around the world.

  2. Cultural superiority, in some ways, is derived from technological superiority.

  3. Loss of technological superiority presents challenges:

    1. Capitalism and freedom move wealth and opportunity elsewhere (market)

    2. Centers of power and cultural status are dispersed (culture)

    3. Unequal laws and norms favoring the former powers are eliminated in favor of decentralized laws and norms (rules)

  4. Coping Mechanism - Focus on cultural superiority.  

    1. Greater acceptance of and integration of minorities and other cultures (cosmopolitanism) using lingering effects of former dominance (e.g. English language, banking system, pop culture).

    2. Greater relative rewards for cultural achievements which are slower to be disrupted by loss of technological superiority; e.g. managers v engineers

    3. Scapegoating/demonization of competition (Putin, Trump (also Xi, Modi, MBS, Khamenei, Orban)) as culturally backward rather than recognizing tradeoffs in focusing on minority rights and cosmopolitan values.  

  5. Downward Spiral

    1. Military overextension and impotence

    2. Commercial overextension and impotence

    3. Cosmopolitan political influences

    4. Detachment from reality due to scapegoating

    5. Reverse scapegoating and societal division.

    6. Internecine conflict and Information warfare

    7. Diminished cultural influence and soft power.


 

Monday, March 18, 2024

The Case Against Biden

The Case Against Biden


Executive Summary

The Biden Administration has been incontrovertibly wrong about the two biggest issues during his time as president.

  1. COVID-19

  2. War in Ukraine

Moreover, he has advanced false narratives in each of these matters to attack his political opponents, severely damaging democratic discourse and global civilization in general.

COVID-19

Covid-19 emerged from a US-funded lab in Wuhan China.  Rather than trying to deal with this constructively, the Biden Administration, in concert with the media and political establishment, has continued to deal with this as a partisan issue.  Jeffrey Sachs looks at the big picture in What Might the US Owe the World for Covid-19?:


A US-funded laboratory origin of Covid-19 would certainly constitute the most significant case of governmental gross negligence in history. The people of the world deserve transparency and factual answers on vital questions.  


The US government (USG) funded and supported a program of dangerous laboratory research that may have resulted in the creation and accidental laboratory release of SARS-CoV-2, the virus that caused the Covid-19 pandemic. Following the outbreak, the USG lied in order to cover up its possible role. The US Government should correct the lies, find the facts, and make amends with the rest of the world.

The Biden Administration inherited the highly partisan covid-19 situation.  However, he was elected as a highly partisan standard bearer, and so can not plausibly distance himself from responsibility.  Now that the worst of the pandemic has passed, the president needs to step up and lead an adult conversation about what happened and how to do better in the future.  If he cannot do this, then we should look for a leader who can and will.

War in Ukraine

The NATO war against Russia has had the exact opposite of its intended effect as advertised by the Biden Adminstration.  The purpose of the war was to weaken Russia and, especially, the administration of Vladimir Putin.  Putin just got reelected with support that western leaders can only dream of.  The moribund Russian military has been revitalizized. Hundreds of thousands of Russian troops have been mobilized and the industrial base of the Russian economy is churning out both high tech and low tech weapons at an unparalled pace.  Russia now has the taste of military success.  The Biden Administration led us into a losing war and now openly panic at the prospect of defeat.

Again, Biden was elected as the highly partisan standard bearer of the party that falsely blamed Putin and Russia for our domestic political dysfunciton.  We need leaders who are willing and able to confront of the truths surrounding our misbegotten adventure in Ukraine.

Additional Considerations?

There are other issues of course.  But none compare to global pandemic and global war.  Antitrust, minority rights, and environmental stewardship, for example, can not be dealt with constructively in the current social climate.  The establishment must stop demonizing Putin and Trump and instead must admit to its own mistakes.  We're seeing what happens when they double down on misinformation masquerading as "intelligence".


Wednesday, March 06, 2024

Our Fake Democracy

The pretense is pretty much gone.  U.S. elections are no more open and fair than are elections in Russia and China.  At the local level, money rules.  At the national level, alternatives are restricted to hose that are establishment approved.  Super Tuesday has come and gone without debate.  Nikki Haley was the only alternative permitted, and she is a puppet of the military intelligence establishment. 

No debate is permitted on the most important subject of war and peace.  Occasionally, public opinion surfaces in the form of Trump, Galloway, or Corbyn, but these alternatives are dismissed as not serious.  The real players know the truth which is not shared with the voters for national security reasons.

Democracy is a good aspirational value.  But let's not kid ourselves about the reality of our political existence.  

Monday, March 04, 2024

The Crime is Revealing the Truth

 So once again, the crime is in revealing the truth: Fall-out from the Bundeswehr scandal

But what exactly are the Germans going to investigate?  The breach of secret communications or the crime that the German government’s own officials were plotting? I would call it a ‘crime against humanity’ in the sense that their intended actions could lead to a world war and the end of civilization on earth.

Regrettably, from all appearances, it is only the first question that interests Herr Scholz, his associates in the coalition government and the Opposition, the Christian Democratic Union. That is what we find in The Financial Times online today in their article “Scholz promises inquiry after Russia publishes tapped military discussions.”  There is great consternation that the Russians have accessed what should have been maximally secure communications lines.  In its coverage today, Le Monde tells a similar story.

The New Domino Theory

Western politicians have been running around like a bunch of Chicken Littles lately screaming that Russia will soon be invoading all of Europe and the United States will be forced to send troops.  This is similar to the Domino Theory as weaponized in Vietnam except it is even less likely.  We are led by buffoons.

Communism was indeed advancing following World War II, and it was an aggressive ideology that claimed that its spread around the world was inevitable.  So there was some plausibility to these Domino Theory warnings that dominated the discourse during my youth in the 1960s.  Russia, on the other hand, has retreated massively and voluntarily in the past 35 years. It has no track record in this time of expanding and no ideology of expansion.  Only twice has it drawn the line -- in Georgia in 2008 and recently (2022) in Ukraine.  In these two instances Russia has intervened on the side of ethnic Russians in conditions of civil war.  There are just not very many other places in Europe with a lot of ethnic Russians, so further Russian military intervention is unlikely, especially far afield in places such as Germany.

There has been a sort of domino effect in the other direction.  Ever since Russia pulled back from the Cold War in 1989, the U.S.-led West has been advancing in Russia's direction, expanding the Western empire.  So it's not that the concept of cascading advances is fundamentally flawed.  Rather, the Domino Theory is used to blind us to other considerations including military strength, civilizational history, and practical politics.

Friday, March 01, 2024

Demonization of Putin

The U.S. intelligence services get away with murder.  The same is probably true of Russian intelligence services.  

I recently read a biography of Putin which was very critical, fitting in with Nancy Pelosi's "one of the most evil men in the world" characterization.  Yet one of the author's main criticism of Putin was that he didn't try to prosecute certain other Russians for crimes.  In other words, certain allied groups in Russia are above the law.  

Putin himself had been certain from the moment he was informed of Nemtsov’s murder that
night that it had been Kadyrov’s doing. The difficulty was what to do about it.
After previous political murders in which the Chechens had been implicated, including those
of Politkovskaya and Ruslan Yamadayev, another of Kadyrov’s opponents, who had been shot
dead when his car stopped at a traffic light in central Moscow in 2008, the killers themselves had
been arrested and sentenced to long prison terms but the investigators had made no attempt to
question those suspected of ordering the murders. Putin regarded Politkovskaya’s murder as
politically inept, but she had been a fierce critic of his regime and he cannot have been sorry to
see her silenced, even if he would have preferred it to happen in a different way. Yamadayev’s
killing had been an intra-Chechen affair, and in such matters he made it a principle not to get
involved.

After the President reappeared in public on March 16, he continued to refuse Kadyrov’s calls.
But the Chechen leader could play that game, too. Ten days later, he flew to Dubai, accompanied
by a large delegation, ostensibly to go to the races, in which some of his horses were running.
While there, he openly taunted Moscow. ‘Some media have even produced headlines, “Is the
Kremlin afraid of Chechnya?”’ he wrote. ‘This is a provocation … The Kremlin has nothing to
fear.’11 That hit very close to the bone. The liberal newspaper, Novaya gazeta, had written
earlier that month: ‘Power means the right to commit violence without punishment. The one
whose violence goes unpunished is the ruler. The murder of Boris Nemtsov suggests that Putin is
no longer the strongest man in Russia.’12

When Kadyrov returned, Putin made clear that he regarded the affair as closed

And yet, we in the West seem to see Putin as an all powerful dictator.  As with our own leaders, however, there are limits to his power.  We should not demonize Putin and the Russian system for the fact that such crimes occur, as the extralegal activity also happens in the West and is ignored by the political leaders.  The more important consideration is the extent to which extralegal activity occurs and is condoned.  From Stephen Cohen in 2018:

There’s an organization called the Committee to Protect American Journalists. It’s kind of iconic. It does good things, it says unwise things. Go on its website and look at the number of Russian journalists killed since 1991, since the end of the Soviet Union, under two leaders. Boris Yeltsin, whom we dearly loved and still mourn, and Putin, whom we hate. Last time I looked, the numbers may have changed, more were killed under Yeltsin than under Putin. Did Putin kill those in the 1990s?

So you should ask me, why did they die, then? And I can tell you the main reason. Corrupt business. Mafia-like business in Russia. Just like happened in the United States during our primitive accumulation days. Profit seekers killed rivals. Killed them dead in the streets. Killed them as demonstrations, as demonstrative acts. The only thing you could say about Putin is that he might have created an atmosphere that abets that sort of thing. To which I would say, maybe, but originally it was created with the oligarchical class under Boris Yeltsin, who remains for us the most beloved Russian leader in history. So that’s the long and the short of it. Go look at the listing on the Committee to Protect Journalists…

Similarly, Putin is demonized because the press and the political system is not entirely free in Russia.  Opposition figures are marginalized and not given access to the biggest platforms.  This happens everywhere to varying degrees including, of course, the United States.  My impression is that, as with extra judicial killings, Russia is not that much different from the West.  Russia is not the Soviet Union in this respect, and the Internet makes it much harder to keep a lid on the truth.  Many in the West have, ironically, come to the conclusion that populist "misinformation" is a big problem and have supported direct and indirect censorship of opposition figures and opinions.  There are sins on both sides, as well as legitimate restrictions, and the devil is in the details / extent of the sins.

I'll close with this Biblical quote from Matthew 7:3-5

3 And why beholdest thou the mote that is in thy brother's eye, but considerest not the beam that is in thine own eye?
4 Or how wilt thou say to thy brother, Let me pull out the mote out of thine eye; and, behold, a beam is in thine own eye?
5 Thou hypocrite, first cast out the beam out of thine own eye; and then shalt thou see clearly to cast out the mote out of thy brother's eye.

Tuesday, February 27, 2024

Jake Sullivan, Cold Blooded Liar or Weak Politician?

I saw an interview with Jake Sullivan on TV yesterday ("Meet the Press", I believe).  I was impressed by his ability to lie seriously and seemingly sincerely.  Just as he did in blaming Putin for the Nord Stream pipeline bombing, he doubled down on Russia/Putin having sabotaged the U.S. elections in 2016 and 2020.  Of course, we know that Russia did nothing of the sort.  Sullivan, most of all, must know since he was at the center of some of the erroneous claims:

That brings us to Sullivan.

As soon as the conspiracy theory was packaged and delivered to the FBI and the media by Sussman, the indictment recounts an exchange between some of those “VIPs”: “… on or about September 15, 2016, Campaign Lawyer-1 exchanged emails with the Clinton Campaign’s campaign manager, communications director, and foreign policy advisor concerning the Russian Bank-1 allegations that SUSSMANN had recently shared with Reporter-1.” The campaign lawyer reportedly was Elias, and the “foreign policy advisor” reportedly was Sullivan.

Sullivan was quoted in an official campaign press statement as stating that the Alfa Bank allegation “could be the most direct link yet between Donald Trump and Moscow.” In the statement, Sullivan said: “Computer scientists have apparently uncovered a covert server linking the Trump Organization to a Russian-based bank. This secret hotline may be the key to unlocking the mystery of Trump’s ties to Russia … This line of communication may help explain Trump’s bizarre adoration of Vladimir Putin.”

The U.S. intelligence community ultimately rejected the Alfa Bank conspiracy. It also concluded that the Steele dossier not only relied on a suspected Russian agent but likely was used by Russian intelligence to spread disinformation through the Clinton campaign.

Yet, when Sullivan was later questioned by Congress, he went full Sergeant Schultz, claiming he basically did not have a clue about the basis or origins of the Alfa Bank controversy or other campaign-orchestrated scandals. Sullivan was adept at laying qualifiers upon qualifiers to render statements useless: “broadly speaking, at some point in the summer, and I don’t remember exactly when it was, around the convention, I learned that there was an effort to do some research into the ties between Trump and Russia.” That will make any false statement claim difficult absent direct involvement in the planning of these “campaign efforts.”

Sullivan denied knowing that Elias or Sussman were working for the Clinton campaign, despite numerous news articles identifying Elias as the campaign’s general counsel. Sullivan just shrugged and said: “To be honest with you, Marc wears a tremendous number of hats, so I wasn’t sure who he was representing. I sort of thought he was, you know, just talking to us as, you know, a fellow traveler in this — in this campaign effort.”

That seems odd, given Sullivan’s long, close involvement with Clinton and her campaigns. He advised her during the 2008 Democratic presidential primaries and later became her deputy chief of staff and policy planning director at the State Department. He was one of the notable names in Clinton’s email scandal and the recipient of her controversial order to strip the classification headings on a key email.  He later rejoined Clinton again during the 2016 campaign as one of her senior-most advisers.

Yet, the lack of disclosure over those behind the “campaign effort” seems suspiciously consistent. Sussman was indicted for allegedly hiding his representation of Clinton in pushing the Alfa Bank conspiracy. Elias was accused of doing the same with reporters on the Steele Dossier. He also reportedly sat next to campaign chair John Podesta when he denied such connections to Congress. Now Sullivan denies any knowledge of the campaign’s early role in these scandals.

It is notable that, when Sullivan was the Clinton campaign’s foreign policy adviser, President Obama was given a national security briefing of Clinton’s alleged plan to tie then-candidate Trump to Russia as “a means of distracting the public from her use of a private email server.” That briefing was on July 28, 2016 — three days before the Russia investigation was initiated.

Upon reflection, it seems to me that Sullivan is not particularly unique within the United States political establishment.  He lies routinely and matter of factly about the most important issues because everybody does and everybody gets away with it.  Meanwhile, the country is hopelessly divided.  Whatever Trump's faults, he's not wrong about the Democrats.  Should we be surprised about the state of our democracy? 

Mocking "Putin's Unprovoked War"

 "Our democracy" has distinct Fascist characteristics, two of which can be found in the phrase "Putin's Unprovoked War", which has been routinely used by the New York Times to characterize the Ukraine/NATO Russia.  

  • Demonizes enemy ("Putin", in this case)

  • Big lie ("unprovoked")


Sunday (2/25/2024), the New York Times unashamedly published The Spy War: How the C.I.A. Secretly Helps Ukraine Fight Putin, with the subtitle: For more than a decade, the United States has nurtured a secret intelligence partnership with Ukraine that is now critical for both countries in countering Russia.

The C.I.A.’s partnership in Ukraine can be traced back to two phone calls on the night of Feb. 24, 2014… The government’s new spy chief… went to an office and called the C.I.A. station chief and the local head of MI6. It was near midnight but he summoned them to the building, asked for help in rebuilding the agency from the ground up, and proposed a three-way partnership. “That’s how it all started,” Mr. Nalyvaichenko said… a C.I.A. supported network of spy bases constructed in the past eight years that includes 12 secret locations along the Russian border… Around 2016, the C.I.A. began training an elite Ukrainian commando force — known as Unit 2245 — which captured Russian drones and communications gear so that C.I.A. technicians could reverse-engineer them and crack Moscow’s encryption systems. (One officer in the unit was Kyrylo Budanov, now the general leading Ukraine’s military intelligence.)  And the C.I.A. also helped train a new generation of Ukrainian spies who operated inside Russia, across Europe, and in Cuba and other places where the Russians have a large presence.

See also How Monsters Who Beat Jews To Death in 1944 Became America’s Favorite “Freedom Fighters” in 1945.

As Hannah Arendt said in The Origins of Totalitarianism: 

In an ever-changing, incomprehensible world the masses had reached the point where they would, at the same time, believe everything and nothing, think that everything was possible and that nothing was true. ... Mass propaganda discovered that its audience was ready at all times to believe the worst, no matter how absurd, and did not particularly object to being deceived because it held every statement to be a lie anyhow. The totalitarian mass leaders based their propaganda on the correct psychological assumption that, under such conditions, one could make people believe the most fantastic statements one day, and trust that if the next day they were given irrefutable proof of their falsehood, they would take refuge in cynicism; instead of deserting the leaders who had lied to them, they would protest that they had known all along that the statement was a lie and would admire the leaders for their superior tactical cleverness.


Our leaders, including the mainstream media, lie gratuitously and carelessly.  We've been in an open proxy war with Russia for 2 years, and now the NY Times casually announces that there has been an active spy war going on since 2014, involving secret bases along the Ukraine/Russia border, spies inside Russia, and commando forces.  What kind of democracy is this where the voters know nothing about the most important facts underlying our march to war?  Informing the voters is an afterthought, delivered by the same news outlet that has consistently delivered the big lies.


Thursday, January 11, 2024

Power Struggle

I’ve been reading the NY Times (headlines only), and the focal points of attention seem to have changed. There is now rarely anything about Putin or Ukraine, and when there is it is often more critical of U.S. policy. For example, there is one headline today mentioning Ukraine: U.S. Military Aid to Ukraine Was Poorly Tracked, Pentagon Report Concludes. There are also articles indicating the military-intelligence establishment is divided internally. Here’s one from Newsweek from last July: Exclusive: The CIA’s Blind Spot about the Ukraine War. From this trend I’ve concluded that the neocons have lost clout.

What I do see in the NY Times headlines is many articles every day about Trump. From the tone of these headlines, I’ve concluded that the establishment’s main goal in the coming year is to defeat Trump and his fellow travellers. This power struggle is now the main focus. I tend to think that the establishment will be successful in defeating Trump and tightening its grip on the institutions which wield power. Perhaps we’ll get a President DeSantis or Gavin Newsom, or 4 more years of Biden, any of which would be acceptable to the powers that be. The important thing is to maintain the status quo with regard to power. And this is not totally unreasonable, considering that Trump is currently the only serious alternative. There is much wrong with our institutions, but we shouldn’t let them fall apart. (Although we've seen that Trump wasn't able to have much of an impact upon our institutions.)

On the other hand, it seems that democracy will continue to suffer. Defeating Trump will come via lawfare and other heavy handed tactics, and the problems which gave rise to Trump will not have gone away. My hope is that the next administration eventually feel secure enough from the populist threat that they will come to embrace needed change.

Tuesday, September 26, 2023

The State of Western "Intelligence"

 Anybody can tell that Russia is winning the war. However, those with access to the "intelligence" (i.e. politicians and mainstream media) learn the opposite. Thus we have Lindsey Graham in May:

"It was reported last week that fearful of leaks, Ukraine has shared their offensive plans with only a tiny handful of people in the West. Apparently Lindsay Graham was one of them, as a new Politico piece reports with joy that Graham has been given a very thorough ‘deep-dive’ of the full offensive plans, which he calls very ‘impressive’. He further says that the Russians are in for a big surprise and ‘rude awakening’."

"Intelligence" apparently consists of convincing politicians and the media that things are not as they seem.

Tuesday, September 19, 2023

Newspeak in the West

Putin's war, unprovoked! Debunked claims of Biden corruption.  I could go on and on.  Our society is sick.

Moral & Pragmatic Bankruptcy of the West

Seeing this headline today in the NY Times reminds me of the West's utter depravity.: Biden Urges Unity as Nations Gather in Shadow of Russia’s War.  Of course, the NYTimes calls it "Russia's War", as if the West has had nothing to do with it.  (See also, Lindsay Graham, Friend of Ukraine / #unprovoked.)  At least the NY Times has the good sense to move on from calling it "Putin's War".

Moreover, these U.S. Senators are not only morally mistaken, but also 180° wrong about weakening Russia.  See From Strategic Dilemma to Strategic Disaster, by Gordon Hahn:

Russian military personnel strength has been increased five-fold... Russian military gains invaluable combat experience in advanced war-fighting... Russia is increasing massively the resources it devotes to military and intelligence development...  the government also plans to increase the number of Russian design centers by over 400 percent from 70 to 300 by 2030 and spend 2.7 trillion rubles to develop the electronics industry... Russia’s enhanced, more powerful military is, moreover, being more forward-deployed to the detriment of NATO countries’ national security... Russia’s territorial gains in southern Ukraine open up the possibility of forming a land bridge to Moldova’s breakaway region of Transdnistria... The war also is threatening to put to an end strategic nuclear arms control between the world’s two greatest nuclear powers... Russia announced that it would be deploying short-range tactical weapons in Belarus, and by July deployment had begun and continues as you read... economic losses in Russia have been limited and manageable, while consequences of is own sanctions and Russian counter-sanctions have driven many of the West’s economies towards recession...   Indeed, the global ripples from the war are reconfiguring global politics, economics, and finances... The most damaging result of the NATO-Russia Ukrainian war for Western interests is the solidification of the Sino-Russian ‘near alliance’ and that alliance’s invigoration of efforts to build an alternative global system to the Western-dominated one... Western sanctions have pushed Russia’s military-industrial complex to sell new technology to the People’s Liberation Army, and Moscow’s reliance on rapidly developing Chinese technology accelerated nascent joint technology developmen and implementation of projects with military applications...  Western pressure on other states to join its sanctions regime further energized the South’s search for an alternative order, which married simultaneous efforts by Russia and China to build a network of anti-Western trade, finance, transport, and even semi-military international blocs. Most notably are the two powers’ stepped-up efforts to construct an alternative non-Western, if not anti-Western global structures for circumventing the American world... It appears that Russia is more popular now among Latin American governments than is the U.S... The same appears to be true in Africa and Asia, with numerous countries seeking cooperation with both Russia and China, despite the latter countries’ tensions with the West, which is demanding implementation of draconian sanctions... Moscow and Beijing have succeeded in drawing oil giant Saudi Arabia away from the West and into the ‘eastern’ orbit. Russia along with friendly Algeria control natural gas prices.

Ukraine has been destroyed with enormous loss of life, but the West considers this a bargain price for the weakening of Russia.  Our attitude seems to be: This is Russia's war. We're just innocent, and fortunate, bystanders.


Thursday, August 24, 2023

Review of "The Lab-Leak Illusion"

 I recently read the Lab-Leak Illusion, a 13,500 word article by Jamie Palmer in Quillette Magazine.  Some comments and observations:

  1. The main meta issue seems to be related to Martin Gurri and The Revolt of the Public and the Crisis Authority (in the Internet Age).  Jamie Palmer's (the Quillette author) take seems to be as follows:

All (lab-leak sympathizers) allowed themselves to be seduced by a heroic narrative in which humble internet gumshoes, armed only with a laptop and a commitment to the truth, humiliated arrogant elites and exposed a cover-up that reached all the way to the top of the US medical establishment.

  1. A related issue is that of conspiracy theories. My take (see also here, here, and here) is that the government had something of a monopoly on conventional wisdom until the Internet made it possible for many more people, working from home, to do their own research.  It's quite obvious that governments are capable of engaging in conspiracies, and that they are more likely to get away with hiding the truth due to classification, censorship, monetary incentives, and the general power of the status quo.  In general, it is quite illogical to generalize with regard to conspiracy theories.  Conspiracies do occur, including conspiracies to spread false conspiracy theories.  Each needs to be evaluated on its own merits.  
  2. My personal exposure to the lab-leak hypothesis was just the opposite of Palmer's characterization.  I read an article which was meticulously documented with dozens of scientific references, many going back before the issue became politicized in the mainstream (i.e. before covid-19). The research in question has a long history and context which was not addressed by Palmer.
  3. Aristotle and Nathan Robinson point out the importance of logic, emotion, and character in discourse.  In particular, I want to stress character and reputation.  Palmer takes the side of the medical establishment in his polemic, while diminishing critics such as myself as being seduced by "Internet gumshoes" and being overly influenced by perceived conflicts of interest. To question the oppositions' motivation and analytical capability is valid, but his particular evaluation of character is not convincing, in my opinion.

For example, Palmer says:

Part of the appeal of conspiracy theories is that they allow a person to feel more intelligent than the drones who passively drift along on the current of received consensus. This is why the February 2020 Lancet statement organised by EcoHealth Alliance president Peter Daszak was such an unfortunate error… The EcoHealthAlliance’s connection to WIV research was hardly a secret, but in the minds of Daszak’s critics, that only made the declaration of “no competing interests” more brazen and galling.

Palmer treats this as a one time lapse. But the Lancet paper stating "We stand together to strongly condemn conspiracy theories suggesting that COVID-19 does not have a natural origin" was signed by 26 other scientists, many of whom had conflicts of interests, and was published in a leading scientific journal. Then, 11 months later, Daszak led a team of scientists from the World Health Organization who "agreed (the evidence) most likely pointed to an animal origin".  So the conflict of interest represented by Daszak in the Lancet paper was not just one person or one time.  It continued well after the issue had been highly politicized.

Palmer also dismisses the revelation, by U.S. House of Representatives investigators, that the scientists behind Nature’s seminal paper from March 17, 2020, The Proximal Origin of SARS-CoV-2, had themselves considered a lab origin likely. Citing Kevin Drum, Palmer claims "the flagrant misrepresentations of those Slack discussions are emblematic of lab-leak theorists’ approach to scientific inquiry:".  But here Palmer is once again confounding the science and the politics.

  1. How did the political situation get out of hand?  
    1. The fundamental research at issue was a legitimate political issue long before covid-19 emerged.  Palmer does not discuss this, yet it is critical to the logic, emotion, and ethos surrounding the debate.  Again, this paper seems to be a fairly objective description of the history leading up to the possible involvement of the Wuhan Lab(s) being related to the emergence of covid-19 in Wuhan.  For example:

Zheng-Li Shi’s group at the WIV has already performed experiments very similar to those he describes, using those collected viruses. In 2013 the Shi lab reported isolating an infectious clone of a bat coronavirus that they called WIV-1 (Ge et al., 2013). WIV-1 was obtained by introducing a bat coronavirus into monkey cells, passaging it, and then testing its infectivity in human (HeLa) cell lines engineered to express the human ACE2 receptor (Ge et al., 2013).  In 2014, just before the US GOF research ban went into effect, Zheng-Li Shi of WIV co-authored a paper with the lab of Ralph Baric in North Carolina that performed GOF research on bat coronaviruses (Menachery et al., 2015).

  1. In the aforementioned chats, dismissed by Palmer via Kevin Drum, the discussion was political as well as scientific:  

It’s in the context of all of this that Arkansas Senator Tom Cotton gets a handful of bizarre mentions. On February 16th, 2020, Dr. Garry shared a Washington Post article by Paula Firozi titled, “Tom Cotton keeps repeating a coronavirus fringe theory that scientists have disputed.” Garry’s comment: “Important to get this out.” The Post piece blasted Cotton for repeating “a fringe theory suggesting that the ongoing spread of a coronavirus is connected to research in the disease-ravaged epicenter of Wuhan, China.” … The ironic thing about this is that Cotton in early 2020 was not saying anything remotely controversial, at least not about this topic... But the early 2020 comments on Covid-19 that earned him years of excoriating headlines were simple, true, even boring. But because Cotton was perceived to have bad or anti-Chinese motives in even bringing up the possibility of lab escape, Andersen did what “anti-disinformation” experts now frequently do on whole ranges of issues involving factual-but-unpleasant matters like vaccine side effects, declaring him not-wrong-but-obviously-wrong, or narratively wrong.

Andersen’s comments were made in private, but he was soon joined in spirit by a stampede of furious pundits…

Humorously, the worst offender was probably Nature, which wrote that “US senator Tom Cotton appeared on Fox News to share his fervent belief that the virus was a biological weapon.” Again, he did nothing of the sort. The Daily Beast might now want to reconsider its own February 16th, 2020 headline, “Sen. Tom Cotton Flogs Coronavirus Conspiracy Theory Dismissed by Actual Scientists,” it being incorrect on two fronts. Not only were actual scientists not dismissing the lab-leak theory, as Andersen’s remark shows, but Cotton wasn’t “flogging” such a theory, unless “considering it as one of the less likely of four possibilities” means “flogging” in Beast-ese.

Of course the worst take of all, in retrospect, was that of Atlantic writer Anne Applebaum, who decried the “suggestion that Coronavirus originated at a super-lab in Wuhan,” tweeting, “Wow. Just like the Soviet propagandists who tried to convince the world that the CIA invented AIDS.”
...
However, even the New York Times framed Cotton’s frankly dull remarks as “echoing the anti-Communist thinking of the Cold War.” All this because Cotton had the temerity to note that the door wasn’t actually closed on lab release, a belief we now know was shared by all of the “actual scientists” who wrote the Proximal Origin paper.

  1. Concluding Thoughts on the Meta Narrative

I disagree strongly with Jamie Palmer's assertion that the lab-leak consensus has "capsized".  My impression is that the foundation of my disagreement is with regard to who we trust to be expert on the matter.  Logic is important with regard to the science and the politics of the matter.  But on a highly technical matter such as this, reliability of sources seems to be the fulcrum of disagreement.  

My opinion is that the national security state is something that has been spreading throughout society, often in ways which restrict or slant public discourse.  With regard to cooperative US-China biolab ventures, I am certain that national security is a major and legitimate concern.  When a global pandemic breaks out in close proximity to such a biolab, we have to consider the possibility that national security concerns play a role on how the outbreak is reported.  This is confirmed by the fact that the Chinese government destroyed much of the data from the biolabs (something Palmer doesn't mention), and by the fact that many of the relevant U.S. documents have been classified or released with redaction. 

There is money to be made, directly and indirectly, by supporting the status quo.  This is not good or bad, per se, but is a legitimate perspective in evaluating the credibility of the various scientists and journalists participating in the discourse.  Daszak, Anderson, Fauci, and company need not recuse themselves from the discourse, but should be more transparent about their conflicts of interest.  The scale of the politicization of the events and the history of their involvement would make this extremely uncomfortable, so it is understandable.  But the rest of us in a healthy democracy should be more open to discussion of issues of character and credibility.

Wednesday, August 09, 2023

Crimea

Crimea as a Focal Point for the Ukraine War

Summary

The current events in Ukraine make sense (to me) if the West is seen as the aggressor with a primary goal being the (re)conquest of Crimea. Thus, the summer 2023 Ukrainian offensive (in the direction of Crimea) is a last gasp attempt to fulfill the initial objectives of the war.


The main inspiration for this idea is an article from April 2023 which made sense to me at the time and has improved in my estimation with age and additional data points: 
The Planning Of The Ukraine Invasion From The Russian Point Of View, by Gaius Baltar

Western Objectives

  1. To tie down the Russian Army in the Donbass

  2. To carry out a surprise attack on the Crimean peninsula

  3. To bog down and bleed the Russian Army in the Donbass with the goal of engineering a regime change in Russia

Russian Objectives

Objective 1 (main objective): To capture Kherson and Zaporizhzhia oblasts to create a buffer zone between Crimea and the rest of Ukraine. 

Objective 2 (secondary objective): Advance on Kiev in an extremely threatening manner. The Ukrainians would have no choice but to take the threat seriously and move forces toward Kiev, including the forces intended for the Crimean operation.

Objective 3 (secondary objective): To force Ukraine to negotiate peace on Russian terms. The Russians most likely assumed that if the Kherson/ Zaporizhzhia buffer operation was successful the Ukrainians might want to negotiate. They would want to negotiate not only because Kiev was threatened, but primarily because their main objective, the capture of Crimea, had been thwarted. This part of the plan was partly successful because the Ukrainians were ready to sign a treaty before the Americans and the British intervened.

Some Data Points

I won't try to list all the data points which support (or contradict) his hypothesis here. Rather, this is more of a notepad.

  • March 16, 2014: In a rejection of the coup and the unconstitutional installation of an anti-Russian government in Kiev, Crimeans vote by 97 percent to join Russia in a referendum with 89 percent turn out. The Wagner private military organization is created to support Crimea. Virtually no shots are fired and no one was killed in what Western media wrongly portrays as a “Russian invasion of Crimea.” (from Ukraine Timeline Tells the Story)

  • March 24, 2021: On that day, Volodymyr Zelensky issued a decree for the recapture of the Crimea, and began to deploy his forces to the south of the country. At the same time, several NATO exercises were conducted between the Black Sea and the Baltic Sea, accompanied by a significant increase in reconnaissance flights along the Russian border.

  • March 26, 2022: Biden admits in a speech in Warsaw that the U.S. is seeking through its proxy war against Russia to overthrow the Putin government. (from Ukraine Timeline Tells the Story)

  • June 5, 2023: Shunning diplomacy, Ukraine plans to take Crimea 'hostage'

According to the Washington Post, a key component of the Ukrainian government’s strategy is to surround Crimea with heavy weaponry, thereby “holding hostage the peninsula that is home to Russia’s prized Black Sea Fleet.”  The plan was previewed four months ago by senior US official Victoria Nuland, who declared that “Ukraine is not going to be safe unless Crimea is at a minimum, at a minimum, demilitarized,” and that “we are supporting that.” 

  • July 17, 2023:  Ukraine attacked for a second time one of Russian President Vladimir’s proudest achievements: the 11.25-mile Kerch Bridge linking Crimea to Russia.  Ukraine initially attacked the bridge last October. The Biden administration’s role in both attacks was vital. [Seymour Hersh]

  • July 26, 2023: Ukraine has launched the main thrust of its counteroffensive, throwing in thousands of troops held in reserve, many of them Western-trained and equipped, two Pentagon officials said on Wednesday, hours after Russian officials reported major Ukrainian attacks in the southern Zaporizhzhia region. [NYTimes] 

  • August 5, 2023:  Early this year, Ukraine began to outfit two separate ‘army corps’ of maneuver brigades specifically for the coming ‘counter-offensive’. These were the 9th Corps and the 10th Corps. The 9th Corps was meant to be the—mostly—NATO-armed and trained one which was famously revealed in the Pentagon leaks.  The 9th experienced catastrophic losses from the start of the offensive on June 4th onward.  So the 9th Corps was not able to reach Russia’s first line of defense and the brigades had appeared to be too degraded to go on any further, many of them withdrawn to refit/reconstitute in the rear. The 10th Corps was then injected prematurely to take over, which is what this new ‘second phase’ has been all about since the end of July. In the first two weeks of the counteroffensive, as much as 20 percent of the weaponry Ukraine sent to the battlefield was damaged or destroyed, according to U.S. and European officials. “The counteroffensive itself hasn’t failed; it will drag on for several months into the fall,” said Michael Kofman, a senior fellow at the Carnegie Endowment for International Peace who recently visited the front lines. But analysts question whether this second wave, relying on attacks by smaller units, will generate enough combat power and momentum to allow Ukrainian troops to push through Russian defenses. Gian Luca Capovin and Alexander Stronell, analysts with the British security intelligence firm Janes, said that the small-unit attack strategy “is extremely likely to result in mass casualties, equipment loss and minimal territorial gains” for Ukraine. [Simplicius76, NYTimes]

I've been trying to figure out why Ukraine and the West have been going all out in this offensive in the direction of Crimea.  They have been taking massive losses of soldiers and equipment with no significant gains.  This makes sense if the war was originally offensive in nature for the West -- i.e. they planned and expected to take Crimea all along.  The current offensive is a belated follow through of the original plan which was initialled derailed by Russia's offensive in the south. The West doesn't have any other plans consistent with their original objective.


Worldview

 I haven't been posting much here of late because I prefer writing in Google Docs. I've been linking most of my great thoughts into ...