Monday, September 21, 2020

Thouights on the Mainstream Media

 I'm writing this post in response to a friend who wrote the following:

I think that part of the problem is that we are not on the same page about major institutions that provide enlightened investigative reporting and editorial positions.  For me the New York Times and the Washington Post and similar newspapers have top notch reporters who have specialized skill sets that allow for in-depth analysis of important issues.  This is overseen by an editorial crew who assure that high levels of journalistic integrity are maintained.  I myself have less confidence in blogs because there is a lack of careful attention, and there certainly is no editorial review.  So--we are ending up getting our news from different sources.  And, this could have the effect of taking us in different directions. 

My feeling is that The New York Times and Washington Post and similar newspapers have deeply compromised reporters that follow the editorial imperatives of their elite sponsors.  They do not practice journalistic integrity, but rather have risen to positions of prominence because they are willing to spout the company line.  Ultimately, the bulk of the media money goes to large organizations that support the United States led global empire against perceived enemies such as Russia, China, Iran, and socialists at home and abroad.  Honest reporters have to work elsewhere, and there are many alternative outlets which provide more balanced and factual reporting and analysis.  

My opinion is not based upon inherent distrust of the establishment.  I have gone back and forth throughout my life as to the degree that I trust establishment media outlets.  Generally, I have been trusting.  But I've noticed that the major media outlets have been broadcasting information from unspecified "intelligence sources" and that this information has been proven faulty in many instances, leading to horrible mistakes both at home and abroad.

Here are some of my previous writings on the subject, along with some analyses from other sources:




This is certainly an important topic.  Our country is horribly polarized due largely to a polarized media landscape.  From Matt Taibbi

We live in a time of incredible political division. Many of us have had the experience of talking to someone whose idea of reality seems to be completely alien to our own. It’s become difficult to have an argument in the traditional sense. People with differing opinions no longer seem to be working from commonly-accepted sets of facts. It’s a problem that has a lot to do with changes in how we receive and digest information, especially through the news media...  

Fundamentally, this means the press has gone from selling a vision of reality they perceive to be acceptable to a broad mean, to selling division. For technological, commercial, and political reasons this instinct has become more exaggerated with time, snowballing toward the dysfunctional state we’re in today...

Audiences are completely siloed. A Pew study that just came out showed that of the people who say Fox is their primary news source, 93% describe themselves as Republicans. For MSNBC, the number is 95% Democrats. The New York Times is 91% Democrats. Even NPR is now 87% Democrats:


So one channel is talking almost exclusively to one group of people, while other channels are talking almost exclusively to another group of people.

So it's understandable 


Thursday, September 17, 2020

2 Views on Biden and Democrats

  1. Our country is deeply and dangerously polarized.  Biden represents the moderation we need if we are not to tear ourselves apart.  He is inclusive and open to conservatives, as demonstrated by the support he has received from Republicans, and will therefore defuse the tension while advocating for better policies in areas such as the environment, education, and economic equity.

  2. The Democrats have been the weaker party since 1980 when Reagan was elected.  In 1980, the Democrats controlled the presidency and had large majorities in both chambers of Congress.  The only Democratic presidents during this time frame have been Clinton and Obama, and the Republicans were particularly contemptuous of Obama, openly declaring that they would make his presidency unsuccessful.  Beginning with the election of Trump or slightly before, the Democrats began responding to the Republicans in kind, openly opposing Trump, regardless of facts, including an unfounded accusation of treason.  It is this movement that has driven the Biden candidacy and plunged the country into deep and dangerous polarization and nationalist madness, employing various spy agencies to set the national discourse.  The election of Biden would validate this dangerous and disturbing turn by the Democrats.  Biden must be defeated to provide space for a more intelligent and moral leadership.

2 Views on Trump and Republicans

  1. Trump should be fought tooth and nail because he brings out the worst in Republicans.  For example, there are racist and violent elements in the Republican base, and Trump legitimizes these elements and brings them to power.  Get rid of Trump and people will see that such behavior cannot be successful in our country.

  2. The country indeed has racist and violent people, and the Republicans have been playing with fire for decades in courting and encouraging these people.  Trump is a particularly inept figurehead for the Republican party and exposes their weaknesses.  Get rid of Trump and we may get something worse, especially if the replacement is weak and of questionable legitimacy.

Saturday, September 05, 2020

The NY Times is a Propaganda Outlet for the White Supremacist U.S. Empire

I don't generally like the term "white supremacist" as it has come to be used as a reference to any injustice in our current system of governance.  "Capitalist" is better, but still too broad.  So here's a stab at a better title:

The NY Times is a Propaganda Outlet for the Chauvinistic U.S. Empire

Chauvinism is a form of extreme patriotism and nationalism, a fervent faith in national excellence and glory. It is an irrational belief in the superiority or dominance of one's own group or people, who are seen as strong and virtuous, while others are considered weak or unworthy.

That's better, in my view.

Here's an example that recently caught my eye:

RUSSIAGATE: NYT, FB & FBI Say Anti-Trump Site, Now Shutdown, Was Russian Effort to Help Trump Win – Consortiumnews

Misgivings about who ran this site, however, can co-exist with legitimate alarm about the combined attacks by the FBI, the Times and other corporate media on the political nature — and not the accuracy — of the published content. That presents the spectacle of a leading news outlet and two social media companies joining a state security agency in an effort to trample press freedom...

PeaceData was accused of being funded by the St. Petersburg-based Internet Research Agency, which the Times says “was very active in the 2016 presidential election, and a recent bipartisan Senate Intelligence Committee report detailed Russian interference in support of Mr. Trump’s election.” In fact, half of IRA’s Facebook ads were purchased after the 2016 election and half of those before the election supported Hillary Clinton, and the other half, Trump. The IRA spent about $100,000 on the ads, compared to the $6.5 billion spent by the Clinton and Trump campaigns.

“Now Facebook and Twitter are offering evidence of this meddling,” the fourth paragraph of the Times story begins, although nowhere in the rest of the article is any evidence presented. The Times says Facebook made its decision based on a report — which the Times does not link to — written by a company called Graphika.

While spotlighting PeaceData’s purported links to the Russian government, the Times fails to provide readers the same service when it comes to Graphika’s own official connections, in this case to the U.S. government.

This pattern of lockstep chauvinism on the part of the U.S. establishment, including many mainstream Republicans as well as Democrats, is why I consider Democrats the bigger threat to the downtrodden of the world than I do Trump and his supporters.  The world is a big place, and there is tremendous institutional and legal support for the rights of black Americans.  This is great.  But the militarized chauvinism of Republicans and Democrats which destroyed the Middle East is on the loose, with the NY Times leading the charge.  

Putin was right about Iraq WMDs; Mueller and the New York Times were wrong. The pattern has continued and intensified in recent years, in my opinion.  I could be wrong, as only the secretive intelligence agencies know the truth of such matters.  But my best guess is that our intelligence agencies have been on the wrong side of critical stories related to war in the Middle East, domestic U.S. politics, and relations with Russia.

Accuracy matters.  And that's why I've used the term propaganda in the title of this post.  

Propaganda is communication that is used primarily to influence an audience and further an agenda, which may not be objective and may be presenting facts selectively to encourage a particular synthesis 

I believe in the enlightenment ideals upon which the U.S. was founded, and which have been improved upon through the abolition of slavery, suffrage for women, and granting of legal rights to other minorities.  The world is a cold, cruel place in terms of power politics, and I appreciate that the NY Times and other establishment institutions are trying to spread the enlightenment, and fight back against Trumpian efforts to diminish enlightenment ideals. 

I'm a humanist and look forward to engaging constructively with as many people, whatever background or political persuasion, as possible.

Monday, August 31, 2020

Empire as the Lens for Politics

I find that the concept of "empire" provides a meaningful context in which to view the current political scene.  In my view, the United States presides over a neoliberal empire whose tentacles encircle the globe.  China, Russia, Iran, N Korea, and a few other places stand outside the empire, while urban ghettos, war zones, and sparsely populated remote landscapes are loosely controlled areas on the fringes.  At the center of the empire in places such as Washington DC, vicious battles take place for power.  

While this may seem to be an unusual point of view, it seems to be to be typical when looking at historical empires.  Certainly the Roman Empire, for example, was engaged in continual warfare on the fringes, while intrigue and power struggles were common in the capital and other power centers.  The current political situation in the U.S. comes with the "territory" that we have carved out in becoming the world's primary superpower.

Within empires, there is an inherent tension between the control and expansion of the outer zones, and the care and nurturing of the heartland.  Thus, in the U.S. today, Trump has come to power as the politician who wants to focus on the heartland, as opposed to spending resources consolidating and extending gains in far away places.  Biden is the candidate of the most powerful forces of the empire who are determined to keep the empire strong not only at home, but around the world.  The empire's success depends upon people of different ethnicities working together.  Thus, Biden represents the forces promoting diversity, as opposed to Trump's focus on the traditional ethnic heartland.

Two factors strike me as interesting in this context:

  1. The emergence of identity politics as a thorn in the side (cancer?) of the empire.
  2. The association of empire foreign enemy Putin with empire domestic enemy Trump.  
The U.S. empire is built on the foundation of the western European enlightenment along with the industrial revolution.  Identity politics, as now embodied via Black Lives Matter, has become an enormous distraction to the establishment.  Originally deployed by the empire in the service of diversity and against the Trumpian forces opposed to empire, BLM has spun out of control and now promotes ethnic hatred.  The empire, led by Biden, still supports BLM but is rapidly losing credibility as BLM undermines the enlightment / capitalist ideological and practical foundations of the empire.  The empire no doubt hopes that sidelining Trump will defuse the more radical aspects of the BLM movement, but it is unclear to me how this might play out in college campuses and Democratic politics.  Until race, and other identity characteristics including gender, sexual orientation, and religious background, are diffused as animating forces at the heart of the empire, the forces of instability will remain potent.  The empire has been playing with fire in playing the race card against Trump and his supporters.

Closely related to these identity politics is the association of Trump with Putin as regressive agents of evil.  Putin has successfully pulled Russia away from the sphere of influence of the U.S. neoliberal empire, and so is a natural enemy of the U.S. empire.  In demonizing Putin, agents of the U.S. empire including both mainstream Republicans and Democrats, have associated Putin with the anti-empire forces at home, who are currently led by Trump.  This reinforces the BLM / identity politics narrative against regressive patriarchal politics.  Radicals who question the foundations of the empire, as established by white men, are aligned with those who seek to spread and strengthen this empire (e.g. neocons).  

The heart of the matter is the extent to which the old cultural order must be overturned.  Is Putin doomed to failure as an old white man clinging to his guns and old school conservative culture?  Or has the west  moved too quickly to invalidate traditions that ungird the empire?  In my view, Putin has the stronger position in this debate.  He has moved, in something of a Trump like fashion, to bolster traditional values,  He enjoys great domestic popularity as his rule has been accompanied by greatly increased stability in the newly downsized Russian empire.  He needn't worry so much about identity politics because:
  • Russia does not have a legacy of black slavery
  • Seventy years of Communist rule in Russia shattered many of the traditions related to gender identity and religious background.  So Putin's Russia is not that of the old patriarchal school.
Putin is, in a sense, consolidating Russian society following revolutionary cultural changes that were enforced via Communist dictatorship.  Much the same is taking place in China.

The U.S. led empire, on the other hand, is so diverse that cultural upheavals leave us with much more of a struggle to consolidate society.  The neoliberal empire is founded on the twin ideals of European enlightenment and capitalist / technological expansion.  The enlightenment principles are faltering in the face of the race card, for example, which has been played to control the MAGA faction.  The capitalist / technological imperative has been undercut by the outsourcing of vital economic activity to fire flung allies and enemies (China) alike.

So even as the empire lashes out at Russia, China, Iran, Venezuela, N Korea, etc. (we have sanctions on countries representing one fourth of the world's population), the world increasingly rejects the sole superpower.  Wars in the Middle East have failed to extend the empire to that region.  Both Russia and China openly defy the empire and provide support and hope for other outcasts such as Iran and Venezuela.  Most strikingly, the U.S. is losing its allure as the shining city of the hill, a beacon of prosperity and peace in a troubled world.  Rioting has spread across the country, while immigration is restricted in the face of both Trumpism and pandemic control.  The American dream is being assaulted, and thus our appeal to would be immigrants is diminished.  Universities are hobbled by politics, as are international corporations.  Financialism has run amok and a crash is a near certainty, which will exacerbate these trends.

Still, perhaps a majority of voting Americans believes that getting rid of Trump will somehow turn things around.  Blacks will be happy to see the face of historic racism (MAGA) unceremoniously booted from power.  Immigrants will once again feel welcome.  Universities will feel less need to consciously intervene to protect minorities.  Foreign affairs will once again become more reasonable and amenable to international diplomacy.  These things are all true.

Yet the problem with empires is that entrenched interests get in the way.  The military industrial complex will still be around, as will the health care vested interests, and the diversity administrators at universities.  Domestic labor will still resent the outsourcing of jobs around the globe.  Countries on the fringe of empire will begin to demand autonomy commensurate with their increased productivity vis a vis the empire's homeland.  Cultural resentments that led to Trump will continue unabated. 

In other words, the internal contradictions of the empire will continue beyond Trump in the direction of instability.  Just as Trump resolved nothing, getting rid of him will resolve nothing.  Or, more optimistically, the election of Trump and potential removal of Trump may be steps in the direction of a new world order that is not centered on the United States.  In this best case scenario, we are freed from American exceptionalism and come to terms with the common humanity with share with others in the world regardless of race, creed, or nationality.

Wednesday, August 19, 2020

Church In-Person

 I ran across this anecdote today, which makes me feel more confident in our decision to not yet resume in-person church services:

On June 14, a man with COVID-19 attended a church service in an Ohio County.

Following that service, 91 additional people from five countiese developed symptoms of COVID-19.  This graphic shows how far the disease had spread by July 4.

Among the notable observations, children 6 to 16 years old are in the chain of transmission, passing SARS-CoV-2 infection on to other kids as well as to adults 

See also We Need to Talk About Ventilation:

Super-spreader events occur overwhelmingly in indoor environments where there are a lot of people... But it’s not only COVID-19’s super-spreader events that are indoors. The rest of the pattern of spread of COVID-19 —when it is spreading slowly, in small numbers—is also overwhelmingly through indoor transmission. 

Getting to Yes -- 2020 Election Edition

I think it's good if we can discuss politics, so I appreciate the linked article about the forthcoming election, and the responses from Steve and Darlene.  My approach is to try to find a sweet spot for constructive discourse, where we can share impressions and learn from one another.

I agree that "it will be a mess" and "a very challenging environment".  On the hopeful side, perhaps such an environment will be an opportunity to change the national trajectory.

I am generally a humanist, and my personal priorities are to lessen tribal and identity politics in both domestic and foreign affairs.  We are all in this together, regardless of race, geographic region, ethnicity, or nationality.  Of course, I am closer to Americans than to people in other countries, and closer to my circle of friends, family, and church than to the Trumpian universe.  But I think the road to success involves broadening our base of support and trust.  (The main other thing I worry about is technology combined with capitalism destroying the human environment.  We have weapons of mass destruction capable of destroying human life on earth if we're not careful.  And we're disrupting the earth's carbon cycle by releasing hundreds of millions of years of sequestered carbon into the atmosphere by burning fossil fuels.)

So how can we take advantage of the unfolding mess?  My idea is to be constructive.  As Michelle Obama said, 'When They Go Low, We Go High'.  For those of us who dislike Trump, the danger has been to overreact as described by Matt Taibbi in The Press Cries Wolf (full article behind a paywall).  Excerpt:

By this week, images of mailboxes became synonymous with voter suppression, and the postal service supplanted the Muslim ban, “kids in cages,” Muellermania, the Brett Kavanaugh fiasco, the campaign to save the job of Jeff Sessions, the Ukraine whistleblower, and a dozen other episodes to become the latest all-consuming Media Fire That Never Dies.

In the Trump years, the news has been covered as an ongoing emergency, borrowing from techniques pioneered by Fox News and perfected through episodes like Benghazi. That story was blown into a frenzy for years, as Fox created the impression that litigating every detail of the Libyan mission narrative was at least 95% of what the average person should be caring about at any given moment.

CNN, MSNBC, the New York Times and the Washington Post are now following the same script with the Trump panics. The pattern is consistent. Day one involves spectacular claims of corruption. By day two, placard-bearing protesters are hitting the streets (“You can’t fire the truth!” a protester in Times Square proclaimed in the Sessions affair), celebrities are taping video appeals, and experts are quoted suggesting Trump is already guilty of crime: OPEN TREASON in Helsinki, “bribery” in Ukraine, or in this case, election interference (some are already speculating that Trump could get a year for the mail slowdown).

Almost always, by day three or four, key claims are walked back: maybe there was no direct “promise” to a foreign leader, or the CIA doesn’t have “direct evidence” of Russian bounties, or viral photos of children in cages at the border were from 2014, not 2017. By then it doesn’t matter. A panic is a panic, and there are only two reportable angles in today’s America, total guilt and total innocence.

The problem with all of these round-the-clock, crash-style coverage schemes is that commentators end up reaching for rhetorical extremes early. Trump’s genuinely abhorrent “zero tolerance” border policy right away morphed into the Holocaust (“Trump’s Concentration Camps,” as Charles Blow put it); revoking John Brennan’s security clearance made him a “dictator”; for making that phone call to Ukrainian President Volodymyr Zelensky, pundit after pundit insisted Trump was guilty of treason, a death penalty offense; it was the same for the Helsinki summit, where Thomas Friedman said Trump’s buddy-movie act with Putin marked a “historic moment in the entire history of the United States.”

This is another technique borrowed from Fox coverage of Barack Obama, who was constantly compared to Hitler and derided as a fascist with “third-world dictator-like arrogance.” The strategy initially galvanized audiences for some shows, but ended up fracturing the conservative audience overall. This type of coverage exhausts audiences, who either become addicted to the cycle of rhetorical highs or repulsed by the relentless maximalist formulations.

As I've said before, I'm not a fan of "both sides do it" in general, such as in comparing Obama and Trump.  In my opinion, Obama genuinely tried to reach out to Republicans and broaden the base.  I could do another post on why that didn't work, using Getting to Yes as a framework.  For now, I'll just say that separating the people from the problem can be useful.  Trump's narcissistic personality, in my opinion, is a real and important problem worthy of discussion and criticism.  (The same could be said about Biden, who is truly comparable to Trump in a number of respects.)  Perhaps the coming crisis will enable more of us to join together in addressing substantive issues, in addition to problematic personalities and media outlets.

It's easy to imagine the election becoming a constitutional crisis, with the Supreme Court becoming involved.  (This would be a continuation of the 2016 election where many Democrats refused to accept the result, and various investigations and legal battles have played out over the last 4 years.)  It's also easy for me to imagine the military getting involved with the support of a bi-partisan group of leaders who realize the need to ensure an orderly resolution of the constitutional issues.  The rules of the game may change.  Politics makes strange bedfellows (adapted from Shakespeare).  Ultimately, I pray for a peaceful resolution of issues and win-win relationships with as many fellow Americans and fellow humans as possible.

Hugs,
Dan
313-580-7082

Saturday, August 08, 2020

Biden: Anachronism for the Status Quo

I stayed up late last night watching Thomas Frank on Anti-Populism, Plus Biden's Most-Stoned Moment Ever | Useful Idiots.  This is a regular YouTube show hosted by Matt Taibbi and Katy Halper.  The bulk of the episode was the interview with Frank, but there was also a powerful segment discussing Biden's apparent dementia.  There was another brief clip of Bill Clinton speaking at the recent John Lewis funeral.  

The episode highlights some contradictions in the current political environment:

  1. Biden has some remarkable similarities to Trump.  He blusters incoherently.

  2. Bill Clinton was arguing against Black Lives Matter anti-police rhetoric during the 2016 presidential campaign.  Speaking like that today would get most white people "cancelled".  Yet, in being against Trump, many BLM supporters are now allies with the Clinton-Biden camp of the Democrats.  Democrats such as Biden and Bill Clinton are allies with traditional black civil rights leaders such as Clyburn and John Lewis.  Biden and Clinton pushed the 1994 crime bill that symbolizes the get tough on crime attitude that is resisted by BLM.  Mainstream Democrats across the country proclaim solidarity with BLM.  

  3. Mainstream Democrats have become vigorous defenders of the status quo, seeing Trump as the problem since he refuses to accept the validity of the mainstream media and other "experts".
      
  4. Mainstream Democrats have embraced the demonization of Russia based upon "leaks" from intelligence agencies.   This is consistent with the anti-populist tactics of the 1890s and 1930s. "Liberals" defend and promote the "experts" even as they have been proven wrong again and again, in matters ranging from hydroxychloroquine to Russiagate to the 2003 Iraq War to the repeated financial bubbles and the 2009 Great Recession.
The mainstream discourse across the American empire is dominated by anti-populist hysteria, even as our technocratic society falls apart due to its own failings.

Personally, I approve of what Bill Clinton has stood for since becoming a major public figure and representative of mainstream Democratism.  He's stood for common sense, for the most part.  However, the times have changed and the current imperative is for the country's leadership to change accordingly.  Most crucially, we need more class based politics, with government support for those who need it the most including especially the working class.  We need less identity politics and international bullying.  These are my personal opinions.

So Bill Clinton and Joe Biden are anachronisms -- politicians who represent issues from a different time.  The current time demands action on labor, the environment, and peaceful/lawful international relations, as well as simplified universal health care, infrastructure, and social services.  Bill Clinton is fine as an elder statesman who has much wisdom and perspective to share.  But what in God's name is Joe Biden, who is older than Clinton, doing as the Democratic presidential candidate?  He's a demented figurehead put up to stop the populists.  He has no coherent policies on labor, identity politics, or foreign relations.  He's solely a marker for the status quo, and hence is supported by moderate Republicans as well as moderate Democrats.

His supporters see him as providing a bridge to a new generation of leadership.  I see him as a tool of the status quo, intended to prevent change until such time as the elite can regain some sort of coherence.  However Biden is so weak that he may not win the election, which will undoubtedly be heavily contested via the legal system.  Even if he does somehow take office, the contradictions noted above will still be around, and chaos may prevail until such time as the military takes control.  A best case scenario, perhaps, is that someone like Gretchen Whitmer emerges as a Putin like figure who leads the nation with a firm grip out of the chaos into which we have fallen.  (Update 9/1/2020:  It's more likely to be a military or "intelligence" person who is in the right place at the right time to lead us out of chaos.)


Tuesday, August 04, 2020

Masks, Hydroxychloroquine, and a Reason to Vote Green

A reluctance to wear masks is one of the hallmark idiocies of Trump supporters.  Fortunately, reason prevails and even Trump has started wearing masks occasionally, while in most public indoor places in the U.S. masks are required.  Of course, there have been no random controlled trials proving that masks save lives, but observational data and common sense indicate that the inconvenience of occasionally wearing a mask is probably worth it.  

On the other hand,  opposition to the use of hydroxychloroquine is one of the hallmarks of Trump opponents.  It is quite probable that hundreds of thousands of lives could be saved by adopting covid treatment protocols including administration of hydroxychloroquine, zinc, and azithromycin to high risk patients who show the first symptoms of COVID-19 illness.  The effectiveness of this HCQ treatment plan hasn't been proven by random controlled trials, but the safety has been proven over a period of 70 years and is on a par with that of wearing masks.  

But this is not something that you will know if you are a mainstream Democrat and consumer of mainstream media such as the New York Times and CNN.  These outlets have been fearmongering and ridiculing Trump supporters with regard to HCQ ever since Trump made some awkwardly optimistic comments about HCQ back in March.  

Unlike the situation with masks, the fake news about HCQ is conventional wisdom.  This demonstrates that the Democrats and mainstream media have the upper hand in terms of misinformation and are a greater danger than is Trump.  This follows the path set by Russiagate and identity politics cancel culture, which are all good reasons to vote Green, and to not vote for Joe Biden.

Saturday, July 11, 2020

Big Picture

Context

I find myself unable to discuss politics with friends and relatives.  The issues have become too emotionally charged and polarized.  In situations like this, it can help to step back and view culture from afar.  I will be thinking out loud here -- trying to get a better handle on how to be constructive in my relationships with friends, family, church, and community.

Human nature may be a good starting point.  Perhaps we can all agree that humans have tribal tendencies, and that these tribes tend to fight with one another.  Secondly, empires come and go as different ethnic groups dominate and try to integrate other ethnic groups into the ruling system.  The United States is currently the world's preeminent superpower, and leader of the preeminent global economic and political systems. 
Despite recently closing hundreds of bases in Iraq and Afghanistan, the United States still maintains nearly 800 military bases in more than 70 countries and territories abroad—from giant “Little Americas” to small radar facilities. Britain, France and Russia, by contrast, have about 30 foreign bases combined.  [Politico 2015]
In terms of military expenditures, the United States is far and away the leader, spending almost 3 times as much as China and 7 times as much as frequently cited rival Russia.  No corner of the world is free from our economic system and accompanying rules.

Human culture can be brutal.  While civilization has tended to make life more peaceful and comfortable for those cultures most closely associated with the empire, the situation is different for cultures on the margins.  Thus, life is dangerous and difficult for many in the Middle East, N. Korea, Africa, and the black slums of the Americas.  Afghanistan, for example, as a fringe area, has been subject to decades of civil war.  Countries such as N Korea and Venezuela that have rebelled against the dominant empire(s), suffer extreme poverty and lack of freedom.  Inner city Detroit has been largely abandoned and suffers high rates of violent crime. 

At the other end of the power spectrum, the centers of power within an empire such as that of the U.S. are prone to uncivilized power struggles.  The rules of democracy or whatever ethos prevails will often be overpowered by that of the military, secret services, and economic elites.  This is an unpleasant fact of human nature and human culture.  We hope that civilization is progressing along an arc of moral justice, as Martin Luther King and Obama might say, but the progress is not automatic nor is it steady.

I was born into the American empire at its apex.  In 1952, the U.S. had recently led the "free world" to victory over Germany and Japan.  Though the Cold War with the Soviet Union was well underway, and China had slipped from the empire's grasp, the U.S. was the preeminent economic and military power.  America's English language base enabled us to inherit the British empire's supremacy where the sun never set, as the old saying goes.  Thus, our cultural domination flowed conveniently on top of our economic and military supremacy, as English became the global lingua franca and our universities attracted the best prospects from around the world.

As I complete my 7th decade, I reflect on what a privilege it has been to be born at this place and time, and wonder what I can do to help my descendants and future generations.  As my father often said in moments of humorous philosophy, Whither capitalism?  I have always been more of a socialist myself,  and outside of the dominant ethos in that regard.  For most of my life, I've been warning that our capitalist ways are unsustainable.  Generally, I've been a soldier in the Democratic tribe in that regard.

Recently, however, I've become estranged from the Democrats, at precisely the same time that my daughter has earned a place at the table with the Democratic leadership.  This is ironic, if not totally surprising.  There is generally a tension between trying to make the world a better place by engaging in party politics (adversarial), and trying to make the world a better place by looking out for the common good regardless of political affiliation.  Another fundamental tension is between political constituency (e.g. America) and the larger grouping of humanity (e.g. everyone on the planet).  I'm a humanist (my religion) and there will always be tension between the political interests of Americans, and the human interests of the planet as a whole.

Thus, I believe that the human condition is fraught with tensions regarding governance, and that my personal situation is no exception.  With this sober context, let's look at some current events that are often too controversial to discuss constructively.
  • Foreign affairs
  • Culture wars in the United States
  • Socialist vs (neo)liberal economic systems
Foreign Affairs

It is ironic that, despite being born when American power was at its apex, I've witnessed a lifelong string of American defeats with regard to foreign affairs:
  1. Vietnam War
  2. Iranian Revolution
  3. Iraq War
  4. Syrian War
  5. Afghanistan War
Balancing these defeats, America won the biggest war of my lifetime -- the Cold War with the Soviet Union.  However, we are now in a renewed Cold War with Russia, and increasingly also with China.  This article about the American experience in Afghanistan provides a stark account of American failure -- How the CIA Made Afghanistan Safe for the Opium Trade.  This history of U.S. involvement in Afghanistan was written over 20 years ago.  Remarkably, our involvement in Afghanistan has only grown more disastrous since then, as we have now been openly at war there for 19 years and have increasingly been on the losing end.  

In Afghanistan, under the guise of fighting communism, the U.S. instigated 40 years of civil war by providing weapons to Afghani and Pakistani drug lords.  Much of the heroin found its way to the United States, exacerbating problems with our own underclass. Eventually, Islamic fundamentalism arose as a reaction to the chaos enveloping the region, turning much of our national attention to fighting more wars in the Middle East as well as terrorism around the world.  We did achieve our immediate objective going back to 1979, which was to get the Soviets to withdraw from Afghanistan.  But we brought untold suffering to the people of Afghanistan and Pakistan, including drug addiction and governmental  corruption.

Fast forward to the present time and anonymous intelligence officials are stoking indignation among Democrats and their media allies such as the New York Times, that Russia is paying the Taliban to fight the U.S.  After all this time, more than 40 years since the U.S. first started supplying weapons to the anti-Soviet drug lords in Afghanistan, we are still battling supposed enemy forces in the same fringes of the empire.  Even Colin Powell has admitted that (with regard to the recent Russia-Taliban reports):
Our military commanders did not think that it was as serious a problem as the newspapers were reporting & television was reporting... It got almost hysterical.
As with Iran, Vietnam, and Iraq, the U.S. moves to buttress the empire have backfired.  Initial successes have been followed by devastating defeats in all these places.  Only in Vietnam, where we eventually admitted defeat and went home, has the situation improved.  Meanwhile, domestically, both political parties continue to support the same people and policies which have proven so disastrous over my lifetime.  People who point this out, such as myself, are thought to be traitors or dupes by a substantial segment of the elite commentariat.

Culture Wars

The failures abroad have turned those responsible to the domestic arena.  If you can't beat Russia in Ukraine, perhaps the problem is a lack of unity in domestic support of the empire.  As in the days of the Cold War, Russia is the most common bogeyman, but China and fundamentalist Islam are also common targets.  
 
Paralleling the various wars of my lifetime, there have been culture wars here at home.  Various ethnic and demographic groups are trying to better their position within society.  As with foreign affairs, our current state is one of seeming agreement by the elites on what the problems are and how to solve them.  When the demagogue Trump won the presidential election in 2016, the elites of both the left and right fought back by blaming Russia and racism.  The name calling and acrimony has descended to levels reminiscent of the Vietnam War / Civil Rights era of the 1960s.  But that comparison is unkind to the 1960s, where the disastrous war was eventually ended due to popular protest, and civil rights were protected more and more over time.

The current situation is more reminiscent of the Salem Witch Trials.  The seeming victor in the culture wars is cancel culture.  I'm guessing this has reached its apex, kind of like the American empire in 1953 when the CIA overthrew the socialist Mossadegh in Iran.  The seeming victories will turn out to be illusory as time goes by.  Attacking people on the basis of their genetic/physical identity is not a recipe for success -- political or otherwise.  And this is true especially in an empire, such as the United States.  

The appeal of the empire is peace and prosperity for increasing numbers of citizens.  Turmoil and witch hunts do not have widespread or lasting appeal, as the Democrats will probably learn when the next batch of polls come out.  However, the current polarization has gone too far for the Dems to turn back.  Tied as they are to the power centers of the empire (media, military, intelligence, economic), the Dems are a formidable monster.  The Republicans, on the other hand, have had their bluff called.  The formidable monsters of previous decades in my life, the Republicans are a thrashing beast of incoherence -- superficially frightening but no longer credible.  Most of the powerful people have deserted the Republican ship.

So the Democratic rage will burn out, while the Republican party tries to reconfigure itself as something credible.  The fraying of the empire will continue as internal rage deflects attention from real problem solving.

Socialist vs (neo)liberal economic systems

The socialist movement represented by Bernie Sanders has been set back.  The visible movement now is based on identity politics, rather than class politics.  Right wingers lump culture warriors and socialists together, apparently having failed to grasp the growing divide.  As the culture war fizzles, the movement will be increasingly discredited by a reinvigorated "center", and socialism will be downplayed as well.

Yet the problems the socialists are trying to solve are real problems that will not go away:
  • The medical finance system is groaning under the weight of unnecessary complexity.
  • Finance in general is experiencing massive recurring bubbles.
  • Global warming is real and the future of life on the planet is in jeopardy.
  • Empire overreach is real and debilitating -- draining resources away from the productive economy and inserting harmful vested interests into the domestic political scene.
The label socialist is problematic, having been associated with godless communism in the public ethos for generations.  However, this could change rapidly.  Alternatively, a new label could catch on.  Eventually we will need to face our problems.

Zooming Back Out

Culture war issues are micro issues -- real and intensely personal, but more about minority rights than majority interests.  Foreign affairs are remote by definition.  Such tensions beset all empires, and all empires eventually decay.  The era of U.S. preeminence is rapidly decaying, with the process accelerating in recent years.  This is natural and survivable.  On a personal or tribal level, it's best to maintain a certain distance from the empire's political upheavals.  From a humanist perspective, it's best to encourage whichever faction is looking at the big picture with the broadest level of human compassion.

Thursday, June 04, 2020

The Democratic Reconquista

The Reconquista (Portuguese and Spanish for "reconquest") was a period in the history of the Iberian Peninsula of about 780 years between the Islamic conquest of Hispania in 711, the expansion of the Christian kingdoms throughout Iberia, and the fall of the last Islamic kingdom in Granada in 1492.

The Arab explosion in the 7th century was fueled by belief in divine favor.  The united Arab armies conquered the world from Spain to India, marching confidently into battle with the backing of the one true God.  Their religious identity solidified in the century following the life of Muhammad.  From my perspective in the 21st century, the Arab rule in Spain was undergirded by fanatical religious beliefs.

The Christians of Spain and Portugal sought to reclaim their lands from these foreign conquerors.  To do so, they sharpened their own religious fanaticism.  The completion of the reconquista in 1492 coincided with the peak of the Spanish Inquisition.  Spain had united in spirit to defeat the Moors, but at the cost of freedom of religion for others such as the Jews.  Truth and rationality were less important than unity under the Christian identity.

Something similar is happening today in the United States.  The traditional Christian / white male led community has united under the banner of the Republican party and backed the more diverse Democratic faction into a corner.  The Democrats are now demanding unity, and are not tolerating dissent within their ranks. 

Some examples of such intolerance:

The campaign to remove Michael Moore’s new documentary from the Internet – led by Moore’s erstwhile progressive “allies” – is a significant advance in the censorship revolution... 
Environmentalists denounced the film as riddled with “lies” and “misinformation,” claiming among other things that Moore used old data to discredit green technology. A campaign to remove the film from circulation immediately took shape... 
The removal of a film by Moore – a heavily-credentialed figure long revered by the liberal mainstream – takes place amid a dramatic acceleration of such speech-suppression incidents, many connected to the coronavirus disaster... 
One problem is the so-called “reputable” fact-checking authorities many platforms are relying upon have terrible factual histories themselves. There’s an implication that “misinformation” by foreign or independent actors is somehow more dangerous than broadly-disseminated official deceptions about U.S. misbehavior abroad, or manufactured scandals like Russiagate. We now expect libertarian or socialist pages to be zapped at any minute, but none of the outlets which amplified the bogus Steele dossier have been put in Internet timeout... 
In Planet of the Humans, Moore and Gibbs make a complex argument. In essence, they charge that people have become dependent upon the high-consumption lifestyles made possible by fossil fuels, and that it’s our addiction to that way of life, as much as to fossil fuels themselves, that is driving humanity off a “cliff.” ... 
The new take is that episodes like Brexit, the election of Donald Trump, the Charlottesville tragedy, a cascade of racially-motivated mass shootings and cases of police violence, and more recently the coronavirus disaster, have all proven that incorrect speech can no longer be tolerated. It’s now understood the consequences are simply too severe, especially for disadvantaged communities. 
In the multitudinous critiques of Planet of the Humans, a creepy kind of rhetorical intersectionality is observed. Moore’s film is consistently depicted as not merely misinformation, conspiracy theory, or Trumpian hate speech, but somehow an interlocking combination of all of these things. Critics all seem to have gotten the same memo... 
With Planet of the Humans, we’ve come full circle. Now liberal critics are deriding all this tree-hugging as not just misanthropy, but supportive of racism and even genocide, using language that blows away Bush-era conservative rhetoric. 
“Protecting the trees has almost always come with a judgment about which kind and color of humans they need protection from,” wrote Kate Aronoff at the New Republic. She added, “Gibbs does not appear to be a white nationalist himself, but his film echoes their approach.” 
In The Nation, which lists Moore on its masthead as a contributing editor, Fox wrote a piece denouncing the film as not only “racist,” but, potentially, an “incitement to eco-fascist population controls.” 
Leah Stokes on Vox wrote the film’s takes on the dangers of overpopulation had “more in common with anti-immigration hate groups than the progressive movement” and expressed hope the film would be “buried.” Gizmodo argued the film has “more than a whiff of eugenics and ecofascism… Who are we going to knock off or control for?”
Given that the primary criticism of Moore’s film is that it unfairly depicts people like McKibben as sellouts, it’s more than a little odd that the apparently serious return criticism is that Michael Moore and Jeff Gibbs want to massacre nonwhite people. This would be laughable were it not for the fact that the campaign succeeded... 
Maybe Moore is wrong about the environmental movement, but these new suppression tactics are infinitely more dangerous than one movie ever could be, and progressives seem to have lost the ability to care. 

Warrantless surveillance, multiple illegal leaks of classified information, a false statements charge constructed on the razor’s edge of Miranda, and the use of never-produced, secret counterintelligence evidence in a domestic criminal proceeding – this is the “rule of law” we’re being asked to cheer. 
Russiagate cases were often two-level offenses: factually bogus or exaggerated, but also indicative of authoritarian practices. Democrats and Democrat-friendly pundits in the last four years have been consistently unable to register objections on either front.


    I will venture to say that FBI “entrapment” type actions in manufacturing crimes, as was practiced on Flynn, got its early start as a more normalized standard procedure after 9-11 with Robert Mueller’s FBI gravitating to using con-artist type informants to infiltrate Muslim communities in order to identify, coerce and entrap the more emotionally vulnerable members into committing acts that the FBI could take credit for as “preventing” terrorism...

    In 2018, the Department of Justice initiated approximately 80,000 federal prosecutions. Two percent of these cases went to trial, with an 83 percent conviction rate. Of the remaining 98 percent of the cases, some 90 percent ended with the defendant pleading guilty; ... The plea process is so prevalent and pervasive in the U.S. Court system that in the Supreme Court’s 2012 decision in Missouri v. Frye, Justice Anthony Kennedy, writing for the majority, quoted a prominent law review article which concluded that “[Plea bargaining] is not some adjunct to the criminal justice system; it is the criminal justice system.”  
    Federal prosecutors are equipped with a considerable range of legal weapons that can be used to compel confessions and discourage a jury trial, including charge-stacking (charging multiple criminal counts derived from a single act), mandatory-minimum sentences which eliminate discretion on the part of a sentencing judge, pretrial confinement, inordinately high bail, threats against friends and family, and the reality that any sentence handed down after trial will be substantially greater than one that could be reached via a plea bargain.  
    The upside of such a process is a streamlined criminal justice system which places a premium on convictions and incarceration without the cost of a trial. The downside, however, is an unacceptably high rate of false confessions obtained by the plea deal process—the National Registry of Exonerations estimates that as many as 20 percent of all plea deal-related confessions are false. 



    It is perhaps the least reported media scandal about the least reported international controversy in recent times—the resignation of Tareq Haddad, a well-regarded journalist from Newsweek, a mainstay of the mainstream media. 
    At issue was what he said regarding the magazine’s refusal to cover the scandal unfolding within the Organization for the Prohibition of Chemical Weapons (OPCW). Evidence has been building for some time that the OPCW cooked the books in its investigation of alleged chemical weapons use in the Syrian town of Douma on April 7, 2018. These allegations served as the justification for a subsequent joint U.S.-U.K.-France attack against suspected chemical weapons targets inside Syria, despite the fact that the OPCW had yet to inspect the Douma location, let alone issue a report on its findings... 
    Under normal circumstances, the leaked documents and first-hand testimony of a whistleblower like “Alex” would have garnered the attention of the mainstream media..  The OPCW whistleblower scandal has all the elements of a blockbuster—heroes, villains, scandal, lies, and cover-up. But fact-based truth is no longer the fuel of the media business that modern journalism is supposed to sustain, especially when the truth can so easily be fobbed off as “pro-Assad” or “pro-Russia.”


    The question we’d ask our friends in the media is when are they going to stop playing the fool by putting him on the air? Mr. Schiff is a powerful figure with access to secrets that the rest of us don’t have and can’t check. He misled the country repeatedly on an issue that consumed American politics. 
    President Trump often spreads falsehoods and invents facts, but at least he’s paid a price for it in media criticism and public mistrust. An industry of media fact checkers is dedicated to parsing his every word. As for Mr. Schiff, no one should ever believe another word he says.

    A fuller accounting by the Times is especially necessary because the media’s pushing of Trump-Russia conspiracy theories was central to an unprecedented and possibly criminal effort to subvert or remove a president under false pretenses. Unless the Times and other sources come clean about who was feeding them misleading and partisan information, we may never understand this momentous chapter of history...
    It is clear now that a prime engine of the Trump-Russia conspiracy theory was the opposition research commissioned from the Washington firm Fusion GPS, paid for by the Hillary Clinton campaign and the Democratic National Committee. The so-called Steele dossier – named for the former British spy who helped compile it, Christopher Steele – included a range of wild tales that deeply influenced federal investigations, including kinkiness with Russian prostitutes and cloak-and-dagger intrigue in Prague. While the FBI’s close and credulous relationship with Steele and Fusion GPS has been exposed in a series of news and official reports, media outlets have not been forthcoming about their interactions with the opposition research firm and how and why they followed its lead into the dead end of collusion... 


    Nobody knows how many people died as a result of the UK/US Coalition of Death led destruction of Iraq, Afghanistan, Libya and, by proxy, Syria and Yemen...   
    The neo-con drive to dominate the Middle East, in alliance with Saudi Arabia and Israel, has caused an apocalyptic level of death and destruction. It really is very difficult indeed to quantify the number of people killed as a direct result of the policy of “liberal intervention” in these countries. Bombing people into freedom has collateral damage. There are also the vast unintended consequences. The destruction of Afghanistan, Iraq, Libya and Syria launched a wave of refugee migration which led to politicial instability throughout Europe and contributed to, among many other consequences, Brexit. 
    For the purposes of argument, I am going to put an extremely conservative figure of 5 million on the number of people who died as a result of Western military intervention, direct or proxy, in the Middle East.

    Now compare that to the worldwide death toll from coronavirus: 220,000. Let me say that again:  Western aggressive wars to coronavirus: 5,000,000 : 220,000. 


    The ruling Establishment has learnt a profound lesson from the debacle over Iraqi Weapons of Mass Destruction. The lesson they have learnt is not that it is wrong to attack and destroy an entire country on the basis of lies. They have not learnt that lesson despite the fact the western powers are now busily attacking the Iraqi Shia majority government they themselves installed, for the crime of being a Shia majority government. 
    No, the lesson they have learnt is never to admit they lied, never to admit they were wrong. They see the ghost-like waxen visage of Tony Blair wandering around, stinking rich but less popular than an Epstein birthday party, and realise that being widely recognised as a lying mass murderer is not a good career choice. They have learnt that the mistake is for the Establishment ever to admit the lies...
    There is no doubt that Douma was a false flag. The documentary and whistleblower evidence from the OPCW is overwhelming and irrefutable...
    None of the New York Times, the Washington Post, the BBC, the Guardian nor CNN – all of which reported the Douma chemical attack very extensively as a real Syrian government atrocity, and used it to editorialise for western military intervention in Syria – none of them has admitted they were wrong. None has issued any substantive retraction or correction. None has reported in detail and without bias on the overwhelming evidence of foul play within the OPCW. 
    The official UK, US, French and Spanish government line, and the line of the billionaire and state owned media, continues to be that Douma was a Syrian government chemical weapons attack on civilians. They intend, aided and abetted by their vast online propaganda operations, to brazen out the lie. 
    In the next instalment I shall consider how the Establishment is brazening out similar lies on the Russophobe agenda, and sticking to factually debunked narratives on the DNC and Podesta emails, on the Steele Dossier and on the Skripals. 
    I could go on and on (as I have in previous posts) -- truth does not matter so much as unity in defeating the Republicans.  Perhaps this is an acceptable tradeoff?  I'm pretty sure that's what most Democrats believe.


    Wednesday, May 13, 2020

    Significance of Trump/Putin Collusion Saga

    I'm not surprised to hear the opinion that the Trump/Putin story is "very old news", and thus presumably not worth discussing.  I feel differently, as here is my understanding of where this story stands.
    1. U.S. intelligence agencies began investigating Trump's ties to Russia in 2016.  They did this my using U.S. "assets" (people who work with U.S. intelligence agencies as business partners rather than employees) who pretend to be connected to Putin.  Joseph Mifsud is the premier example of this, but most if not all of the Russian contacts mentioned in the Mueller report fall into this category.
    2. The Hillary Clinton presidential campaign hires a firm to collect opposition research on Donald Trump.  The firm employs Christopher Steele who creates a dossier full of lurid tales and shady connections between Trump and Putin/Russia.  We now know that this opposition research was false. This is not disputed by anyone and as a result Mueller's team didn't even investigate the Steele Dossier.
    3. The Steele dossier was leaked to the media before the 2016 election as "intelligence".  It was given tremendous publicity and credibility before and after the election by the mainstream media, and was the basis for wiretapping members of Trump's team and warning the country about Russian interference in the election and extensive misinformation from Adam Schiff, Brennan, and other politicians, media figures, and former intelligence agents / employees.
    4. After years of investigation, Mueller's team uncovered no sign Russian collusion.  Rather than admit this, the Democrats, the mainstream press, and the involved intelligence personnel accused William Barr of lying about the findings.  They also have implied that there really was collusion but that Trump obstructed justice.
    5. Another year has passed, and the debunking of the Trump/Russia collusion narrative has continued as additional facts have come out.   The most important of these was the Inspector General's report in December, but the recent dropping of charges also fits.
    6. The Democrats and mainstream media have doubled down on the debunked narrative instead of admitting that mistakes were made.  For example, the New York Times recently (May 9) editorialized on William Barr’s Perversion of Justice.  Quoting:
    Last year, barely a month after he was confirmed to his post, he stood before the American people and misrepresented the contents of the long-awaited report by Robert Mueller, the special counsel who investigated ties between the Trump campaign and the Russian government in 2016.
    The report itself, at 448 pages, documented extensive evidence of those ties, as well as multiple instances of lying and obstruction of justice by Mr. Trump and other top government officials. Mr. Barr’s four-page summary claimed the opposite — that Mr. Mueller had found no collusion or obstruction of justice. Mr. Mueller protested, and yet weeks passed before Americans could see the report themselves and discover just how much Mr. Barr had twisted its findings to benefit Mr. Trump.

    Short version:  Democrats paid intelligence operatives who invented story that Trump was treasonous.  The false stories were leaked to the media before the election and embellished by intelligence figures after Trump assumed the presidency, with continued"leaking" of false intelligence that Trump had been engaged in treasonous behavior.  The Democrats and mainstream media declared the treasonous accusations to be true and engaged in a multiyear investigation of the Trump Administration by the FBI.  When the accusations of treason or any sort of improper behavior with regard to Russia were found not to be true, the Democrats and mainstream refused to admit that they were wrong, but rather blamed Trump for obstruction of justice.  At present, they are attacking the Attorney General for daring to discuss what happened and how this combination of intelligence agencies working with one political party against the other is a threat to our democracy.

    We have a constitutional crisis, and the NY Times is using Trump's alleged collusion with Russia (citing the Mueller Report), as evidence against the Attorney General.

    Wednesday, April 29, 2020

    Political Economy Musings

    I wrote here about the political prospects for 2020 back on 10/2/2019.  I'd like to revisit a few of my observations / predictions from that time.
    I think the Dems will nominate Warren, who is the only plausible candidate to bridge the Clinton-Sanders divide that plagues the party.  
    I missed this one.  While I was correct that opposition to Sanders would stop him from getting the nomination, I overestimated the ability of Warren and the Democrats to bridge the gap.  Warren seems to have been taken out by the "centrists" who thought she was too radical.  She reacted by moving to the center and trying to draw contrasts between herself and Sanders.  As a result, Sanders supporters (such as myself) moved away from Warren, while the centrists stayed with the more status quo candidates.

    Looking at this in more depth, it seems that I underestimated the inflexibility of the status quo.  Sanders' signature issue was Medicare for All, in the sense of a Canadian style single payer health care system.  This is very practical except to the degree which it would disrupt the vested interests in the healthcare industry.  The COVID-19 situation gives further clarity to the dysfunction of our current system, and the advantages of a Canadian type system.  The Bloombergs and Bidens of the Democratic party seem to be continuing down the wrong path.

    On the other hand, not only Sanders but all the candidates were drifting far to the left before Bloomberg jumped in.  They were mostly in favor of forgiving student debt, going easy on illegal immigration, and supporting some sort of green new deal.  Conservatives such as Michael Bennet and John Hickenlooper were among the first to drop out of the presidential race.  Future conservatives such as Pete Buttigieg were on the liberal side (e.g. Medicare for All) early in the campaign.

    Bernie Sanders seemed to have the only coherent campaign, and the pushback was fierce.  In addition to the mainstream press which had been strongly against him in 2016, all the other Democratic candidates got the message that he was beyond the pale, as were his policies.  By the time of the crucial South Carolina and Super Tuesday primaries, the debate consensus had shifted to the attitude that Sanders was too much of a socialist too win the general election.  In about one week, he moved from being the overwhelming favorite to virtually all other candidates endorsing Biden.  The Democratic status quo held, although Biden was not the fresh face that many had hoped to see.
    If the Democrats nominate a status quo figure such as Biden, Republicans will be in a better position to benefit from economic weakness. 
    The economy has cratered, but due to natural disaster as opposed to manmade failure.  Trump is widely seen (correctly) as having bungled the response, so Biden has thus far not taken much heat as a symbol of the status quo.  Rather, Trump is a lightning rod for the status quo failures.  Democrats have been wise to keep Biden out of the spotlight, but this cannot continue through a presidential election.

    The economy has cratered, but federal stimulus has poured in and the stock market has been resilient.  Uncertainty reigns, but most expect to see a return to the status quo prior to the pandemic.  Yet changes such as reduced economic globalization and increased labor power are likely to persist.  These factors point to higher prices, offset somewhat by a weak government and a weak economy.

    I sense that the U.S. is desperate for a strong leader.  Sanders would have been a good leader, but hounded by all parts of the status quo.  Joe Biden is weak in that he is a figurehead or compromise candidate, and will be in a weak position if elected in my opinion.  I would expect a lot of infighting behind the scenes in a Biden administration.  Trump is weak, with little support from the establishment including the mainstream media.  There is something of a vacuum of leadership at the moment.

    As much as I'd like a progressive like Sanders or FDR to be the strong president that people crave, it must be acknowledged that the Democratic party is moving in the opposite direction.  Many Dems now associate with CIA, FBI, and renewed cold war against Russia and China.  They are in lock step with the media to a frightening degree.  The stage is set for the mother of all negative presidential campaigns, as the Republicans have long been strong in this regard and Trump is a particularly savage negative campaigner.  The situation may get so ugly that we get some sort of military coup.

    Unfortunately or fortunately depending upon your perspective, the U.S. military is much stronger at home than it is in its role as defender of the neoliberal empire around the world.  China and Russia are out of our control, as is much of the Middle East, where the U.S. has suffered a string of defeats, and Africa.  The U.S. military-intelligence-industrial establishment is likely to focus on the homefront, further marginalizing populists while at the same time enacting some populist reforms.

    Only a firm right wing military type will be able to implement socialist reforms to our healthcare, legal, and political systems.  Such a figure will also curtail the culture wars in favor of patriotism and strict enforcement of select laws. 

    How we get from here to there seems fairly straightforward, if impossible to predict with regard to details.  The Dems have already attempted to remove Trump via a couple of intelligence agency inspired investigations and charges of treason.  And the Dems demonstrated in the Democratic primaries that they will do whatever it takes to prevail.  But the Republicans have some weapons too, including Attorney General Barr and the truth with regard to the Russiagate offensive by the Dems.  With the Covid-19 uncertainly cancelling remaining primaries, it is not clear that the presidential campaign can go ahead on a business as usual basis.  The chances that Reps and Dems will agree on new rules to accommodate the virus without breaking down in partisan rancor are slight.   Biden is a mirror image of Trump, with allegations of sexual assault, lying pathologically, and poor mental acuity.  There is a need for someone at least moderately credible to take charge, and only a military type man would be acceptable to the powers that be.

    With regard to the economy, chaos looms.  The political chaos described above is matched by the uncharted territory of the global economy.  Supply chains have been disrupted, unemployment is soaring, and there is no clear path to recovery.  Stay in cash and near cash equivalents for the time being.  When the coup has been accomplished and the new strongman allows markets to find their own way again, then will be the time to reinvest.

    The center of U.S. politics has not held.  Trump was elected in 2016, and the status quo has continued to unravel since then.  Culture wars and identity politics have brought the Dems to the Biden candidacy, which would seem to be the end of that road.  Crumbling empire and domestic impotence make it inevitable that there will be a coup of one sort or another, and the democratic path for populist change is blocked. 






    Thursday, April 16, 2020

    Russiagate Origins Revisited

    On August 26, 2019, I wrote a post entitled What Was Russiagate All About?
    Why was a special counsel appointed to investigate allegations of collusion between the Trump campaign and Russia?  And why were these baseless allegations taken so seriously by the mainstream press and Democratic politicians?  Why did the press, as well as Mueller himself, fail to acknowledge that the whole story was fabricated?
    I just reread this post and my best guesses as to what happened seem to have been remarkably accurate (if I do say so myself).  One item to be added is that it now appears that Russian disinformation played a significant role in getting these investigations started.  Also, it appears that the FBI knew or was warned about this, but chose to ignore these facts.

    Declassified Horowitz Footnotes Show Obama Officials Knew Steele Dossier Was Russian Disinformation Designed To Target Trump
    Newly declassified footnotes from Department of Justice Inspector General Michael Horowitz’s December FBI report reveals that senior Obama officials, including members of the FBI’s Crossfire Hurricane team knew the dossier compiled by a former British spy during the 2016 election was Russian disinformation to target President Donald Trump. 
    Further, the partially declassified footnotes reveal that those senior intelligence officials were aware of the disinformation when they included the dossier in the Obama administration’s Intelligence Communities Assessment (ICA). 
    As important, the footnotes reveal that there had been a request to validate information collected by British spy Christopher Steele as far back as 2015, and that there was concern among members of the FBI and intelligence community about his reliability. 
    So the Russiagate investigation pursued by Democrats along with the mainstream media was based upon a combination of incompetence and political interference by the intelligence community.  The mainstream has refused to accept this however and was goaded into an impeachment trial by intelligence operatives working with colleagues in the "interagency".  Thus, the Russiagate investigation has metastasized into a cold civil war.


    Monday, April 13, 2020

    Media, Military Intelligence Complex, and Other Ramblings


    A Letter from 2/22/2020


    Greetings Fellow Citizens,

    I was asked last night about my sources of news.  I mentioned a few (The Grayzone, Current Affairs, Consortium News, RealClearPolitics -- a news aggregator which includes a variety of sources including both Democratic and Republican leaning publications, i.e. Rolling Stone, The Atlantic, American Greatness, New York Times, TN Star, Fox News, TAP, The Hill, Foreign Affairs, Defense News, Fortune, Las Vegas Review Journal, Vox, RCP, Daily Caller, Washington Post, San Diego Union Tribune, ...).

    But the issue when talking to skeptics such as most people I know is that news from little known sources is not convincing.  It's like trying to convince devout Christians that there are flaws in the Bible.  One way of dealing with such situations is to highlights inconsistencies in the mainstream media outlets.  That's one reason why I read the mainstream media, even though I feel that they often spin the news in favor of the vested interests.  If I can point out that Russiagate, for example, has been discredited by even the NY Times, then it carries more weight than if I tell you I get my news from Consortium News.

    So here's one example from the NY Times, from December 11, 2019:  We Just Got a Rare Look at National Security Surveillance. It Was Ugly.  This was a report following the Inspector General (Michael Horowitz - a Democrat) report on the FISA authorized wiretapping of Trump associate Carter Page. 

    The Justice Department’s independent inspector general, Michael E. Horowitz, and his team uncovered a staggeringly dysfunctional and error-ridden process in how the F.B.I. went about obtaining and renewing court permission under the Foreign Intelligence Surveillance Act, or FISA, to wiretap Carter Page, a former Trump campaign adviser.

    But the inspector general found major errors, material omissions and unsupported statements about Mr. Page in the materials that went to the court. F.B.I. agents cherry-picked the evidence, telling the Justice Department information that made Mr. Page look suspicious and omitting material that cut the other way, and the department passed that misleading portrait onto the court.

    To give just three examples:

    First, when agents initially sought permission for the wiretap, F.B.I. officials scoured information from confidential informants and selectively presented portions that supported their suspicions that Mr. Page might be a conduit between Russia and the Trump campaign’s onetime chairman, Paul Manafort.

    But officials did not disclose information that undercut that allegation — such as the fact that Mr. Page had told an informant in August 2016 that he “never met” or “said one word” to Mr. Manafort, who had never returned Mr. Page’s emails. Even if the investigators did not necessarily believe Mr. Page, the court should have been told what he had said.

    Second, as the initial court order was nearing its expiration and law-enforcement officials prepared to ask the surveillance court to renew it, the F.B.I. had uncovered information that cast doubt on some of its original assertions. But law enforcement officials never reported that new information to the court.

    Specifically, the application included allegations about Mr. Page contained in a dossier compiled by Christopher Steele, a former British intelligence agent whose research was funded by Democrats. In January 2017, the F.B.I. interviewed Mr. Steele’s own primary source, and he contradicted what Mr. Steele had written in the dossier.

    The source for Mr. Steele may, of course, have been lying. But either way, officials should have flagged the disconnect for the court. Instead, the F.B.I. reported that its agents had met with the source to “further corroborate” the dossier and found him to be “truthful and cooperative,” leaving a misleading impression in renewal applications.

    Finally, the report stressed Mr. Page’s long history of meeting with Russian intelligence officials. But he had also said that he had a relationship with the C.I.A., and it turns out that he had for years told the agency about those meetings — including one that was cited in the wiretap application as a reason to be suspicious of him.

    Here's a piece I read by former U.K diplomat Craig Murray.  Murray goes to original source documents (e.g. reports by the Organization for the Prohibition of Chemical Weapons - OPCW).  The Terrifying Rise of the Zombie State Narrative.  In addition to referencing publicly available source documents, Murray includes consideration of OPCW whistleblowers who are not given space in the mainstream media, for the obvious reason that the whistleblower reports contradict the U.S. / British narrative that Russia and Assad used chemical weapons at Douma in Syria.

    The ruling Establishment has learnt a profound lesson from the debacle over Iraqi Weapons of Mass Destruction. The lesson they have learnt is not that it is wrong to attack and destroy an entire country on the basis of lies. They have not learnt that lesson despite the fact the western powers are now busily attacking the Iraqi Shia majority government they themselves installed, for the crime of being a Shia majority government.

    No, the lesson they have learnt is never to admit they lied, never to admit they were wrong. They see the ghost-like waxen visage of Tony Blair wandering around, stinking rich but less popular than an Epstein birthday party, and realise that being widely recognised as a lying mass murderer is not a good career choice. They have learnt that the mistake is for the Establishment ever to admit the lies.

    The Establishment had to do a certain amount of collective self-flagellation over the non-existent Iraqi weapons of mass destruction, over which they precipitated the death and maiming of millions of people...

    These situations are now avoided by the realisation of the security services that in future they just have to brazen it out. The simple truth of the matter – and it is a truth – is this. If the Iraq WMD situation occurred today, and the security services decided to brazen it out and claim that WMD had indeed been found, there is not a mainstream media outlet that would contradict them.

    The security services outlet Bellingcat would publish some photos of big missiles planted in the sand. The Washington Post, Guardian, New York Times, BBC and CNN would republish and amplify these pictures and copy and paste the official statements from government spokesmen. Robert Fisk would get to the scene and interview a few eye witnesses who saw the missiles being planted, and he would be derided as a senile old has-been. Seymour Hersh and Peter Hitchens would interview whistleblowers and be shunned by their colleagues and left off the airwaves. Bloggers like myself would be derided as mad conspiracy theorists or paid Russian agents if we cast any doubt on the Bellingcat “evidence”. Wikipedia would ruthlessly expunge any alternative narrative as being from unreliable sources. The Integrity Initiative, 77th Brigade, GCHQ and their US equivalents would be pumping out the “Iraqi WMD found” narrative all over social media. Mad Ben Nimmo of the Atlantic Council would be banning dissenting accounts all over the place in his role as Facebook Witchfinder-General.

    Does anybody seriously wish to dispute this is how the absence of Iraqi WMD would be handled today, 16 years on?

    If you do wish to doubt this could happen, look at the obviously fake narrative of the Syrian government chemical weapons attacks on Douma. The pictures published on Bellingcat of improvised chlorine gas missiles were always obviously fake. Remember this missile was supposed to have smashed through ten inches of solid, steel rebar reinforced concrete (editor's note: there is a photo on linked website showing the missles).

    As I reported back in May last year, that the expert engineers sent to investigate by the Organisation for the Prohibition of Chemical Weapons (OPCW) did not buy into this is hardly surprising.

    The highlights are:

    “No nerve agents had been detected in environmental or bio samples”
    “The experts were conclusive in their statements that there was no correlation between symptoms and chlorine exposure”
    “The experts were also of the opinion that the victims were highly unlikely to have gathered in piles at the centre of the respective apartments, at such a short distance from an escape from any toxic chlorine gas to much cleaner air”.

     We see now how the OPCW managed to produce a report which was the opposite of the truth. Ian Henderson, the OPCW engineer who had visited the site and concluded that the “cylinder bombs” were fakes, had suddenly become excluded from the “fact finding mission” when it had been whittled down to a “core group” – excluding any engineers (and presumably toxicologists) who would seek to insert inconvenient facts into the report.

    That the consequences of the fake Douma incident were much less far-reaching than they might have been, is entirely due (and I am sorry if you dislike this but it is true) to the good sense of Donald Trump. Trump is inclined to isolationism and the fake “Russiagate” narrative promoted by senior echelons of his security services had led him to be heavily sceptical of them. He therefore refused, against the united persuasion of the hawks, to respond to the Douma “attack” by more than quick and limited missile strikes. I have no doubt that the object of the false flag was to push the US into a full regime change operation, by falsifying a demonstration that a declared red line on chemical weapon use had been crossed.

    There is no doubt that Douma was a false flag. The documentary and whistleblower evidence from the OPCW is overwhelming and irrefutable. In addition to the two whistleblowers reported extensively by Wikileaks and the Courage Foundation, the redoubtable Peter Hitchens has his own whistleblowers inside OPCW who may well be different persons. It is also great entertainment as well as enlightening to read Hitchens’ takedown of Bellingcat on the issue...

    None of the New York Times, the Washington Post, the BBC, the Guardian nor CNN – all of which reported the Douma chemical attack very extensively as a real Syrian government atrocity, and used it to editorialise for western military intervention in Syria – none of them has admitted they were wrong. None has issued any substantive retraction or correction. None has reported in detail and without bias on the overwhelming evidence of foul play within the OPCW.

    Those sources who do publish the truth – including the few outliers in mainstream media such as Peter Hitchens and Robert Fisk – continue to be further marginalised, attacked as at best eccentric and at worse Russian agents.

    What we are seeing is the terrifying rise of the zombie state narrative in Western culture. It does not matter how definitively we can prove that something is a lie, the full spectrum dominance of the Establishment in media resources is such that the lie is impossible to kill off, and the state manages to implant that lie as the truth in the minds of a sufficient majority of the populace to ride roughshod over objective truth with great success. It follows in the state narrative that anybody who challenges the state’s version of truth is themselves dishonest or mad, and the state manages also to implant that notion into a sufficient majority of the populace.

    These are truly chilling times.

    I (Dan) remember the Douma incident at the time (April 7, 2018) as being highly suspicious.  The Syrian Army was just completing their defeat of Isis/Al Qaeda in southern Syria.  Everyone knew that the Syrians had won and Isis would be retreating.  It certainly seemed to me at the time that it's highly unlikely that Assad would bring out chemical weapons when the battle was already won.  Much more likely, the Isis/Al Qaeda rebels were on the brink of defeat and made a desperate false flag attempt to get the U.S. to intervene. 

    Ah well, I could be wrong about all this.



    A lot more follow up on our conversation last night.  I don't expect any of you to read this unless you are interested in knowing why I hold heretical (for Democrats) views regarding the role of the mainstream media, Democrats, and the intelligence community with regard to Trump's alleged collusion with Russia, and related threats to democracy.

    Regarding the Stone prosecution -- Seeing Through the Lies – US Edition

    To finish with Stone, the ludicrous vindictiveness of the prosecutors in pushing for a seven to nine year jail sentence for an offence that was really no more than wasting investigators’ time with his fanatasies, was rightly called out by Donald Trump. The notion that Roger Stone threatened witnesses is problematical. Randy Credico, the only person Stone was convicted of threatening, has written to the judge asking for Stone not to be jailed and making plain he did not feel threatened. He had known Stone for years and was used to his blustering talk, which Randy never took as intended to be a serious threat...

    To maintain this stance in the face of all factual evidence requires great skill and dexterity from Guardian journalists. Fortunately for the Guardian it does not lack for fantasist Russophobe fabricators like Luke Harding or for more subtly corrupt spinners like David Smith, who last week wrote of Stone that “He was the sixth former Trump aide to be convicted in cases arising from the special counsel Robert Mueller’s investigation into Russian interference in the 2016 presidential election.”

    The oleaginous David Smith omitted to note what any half honest human being would consider a very pertinent fact – that not one of those convictions had anything at all to do with Russian interference in the 2016 Presidential election, being either entirely unrelated tax and corruption matters turned up while trawling, or as with Stone being questions of process. Stone’s case is unique in that not only did his conviction not relate to any Russian interference, it was for promoting precisely the same ludicrous fantasy that the Guardian is promoting. It was illegal for Stone to persist in telling his lies on oath; there is no legal bar to the Guardian promoting the same Trump/Wikileaks/Russia fantasy ad nauseam.

    Yet we have the spectacle of Julian Assange standing before a judge facing extradition to the United States and up to 175 years in jail for “espionage”, when everything Wikileaks has ever published has a 100% record for truth and accuracy.


    As is his wont, the president went bonkers on Twitter upon learning of the recommendation, calling it “horrible and very unfair” and a major “miscarriage of justice” because “the real crimes are on the other side” — i.e., the Russia-probe investigators — yet “nothing happens to them.” While the Justice Department was obviously aware of the president’s tweet, as well as press reporting about the harshness of the prosecutors’ sentencing recommendation, the DOJ and the White House have had no communications about the case, according to both the president and a spokeswoman for the attorney general.

    It seems like Trump has a point.  But, no, he shouldn't be tweeting his opinions as that could be exerting inappropriate pressure on the Attorney General and others.  (I was wrong about this last night, I believe, and … was right.)


    Barr allowed the Mueller probe to reach its conclusion unmolested. The extent of his alleged interference was, prior to the release of the report, summarizing its findings in a way that wasn’t harsh or detailed enough for Trump’s critics.

    Finally, he declined to prosecute former Department of Justice official and frequent Trump target Andrew McCabe for lying to investigators. If Barr is really Trump’s Roy Cohn, his personal enforcer masquerading as a top law-enforcement official, nailing McCabe would have been his Job One.

    So, is Trump right that Democrats caught lying, like McCabe, have not been prosecuted for perjury?  Consider You Can’t Fool All the People All the Time. 

    The Horowitz report is not some ordinary rebuke, but an epic assault that has left the FBI reeling. After fawning over the bureau for years, the New York Times tried to salvage a shred of self-respect by declaring that even though it “painted a bleak portrait of the FBI as a dysfunctional agency,” all was not lost because the inspector general uncovered “no evidence that the mistakes were intentional or undertaken out of political bias.”

    This was incorrect. Horowitz made it clear in his Dec. 11 appearance before the Senate judiciary committee that while there was “no evidence that the initiation of the investigation was motivated by political bias,” the question gets “murkier” when it comes to subsequent FBI actions like withholding or doctoring evidence. Considering that FBI attorney Kevin Clinesmith, the man who allegedly falsified evidence against Page, is a never-Trumper who once texted “viva le resistance,” it’s hard to see how bias could not have been a factor.

    The inspector general lists seventeen “significant errors” the bureau made in applying for a secret surveillance warrant. It failed to inform the court that Page had been a CIA informant for years and had been found to have been truthful throughout; that he told an undercover agent that he “literally never met” or “said one word to” Paul Manafort, his alleged co-conspirator, and that Manafort had never responded to any of his emails; that a source for ex-MI6 agent Christopher Steele’s famous “golden showers” dossier was known to be a “boaster” and an “egoist” who may “engage in some embellishment”; and that professional associates of Steele said he “[d]emonstrates lack of self-awareness [and] poor judgment” and “pursued people with political risk but no intelligence value.”

    Steele, the man who turned US politics upside down, was a flake in other words while Page was more likely on the up and up. Yet the FBI assumed the opposite. Perhaps the most amazing section in Horowitz’s report concerns a Steele informant who confessed that reports of Trump’s sexual escapades in the Moscow Ritz Carlton were “just talk,” conversations he or she “had with friends over beers,” and statements made in “jest.” Yet the Steele dossier reported them as a real, and a credulous press lapped them all up. Steele’s supposed high-level Kremlin contacts, the source added, were individuals “who may have had access” – and, then again, may not have. Corroboration of Steele’s findings was meanwhile “zero.”
    Yet this is the document that the FBI continued using to pursue Page and Trump and convince the public that collusion was genuine.


    So, who are the weakest links as Durham’s investigation moves forward? One is surely Kevin Clinesmith, a lawyer in Comey’s FBI who is highlighted in the Horowitz Report (pages 186-190). Sen. Lindsey Graham mentioned those pages in his Tuesday press conference. In them, Horowitz presents evidence that Clinesmith not only altered official documents, he completely changed their meaning. The altered documents painted Carter Page as a foreign spy; the originals said there was no evidence for that. The exculpatory evidence was hidden from the Foreign Intelligence Surveillance Courts. The lies helped gain a secret warrant to spy on Page.

    How important was the Steele dossier to gaining the warrant? The FBI’s own legal counsel said, in internal documents, “this is essentially a single source FISA” (p. 132). That source was the Steele dossier. (Remember when Comey and all the Democrats denied that? There was lots more evidence in the applications, they said. There wasn’t.) Horowitz underscores the dossier’s significance when he concludes it was “central and essential” to gaining the surveillance warrant (p. 359).

    How did the FBI and DoJ know the Steele dossier was garbage? Because they couldn’t substantiate any of its key claims and because they interviewed Steele’s most important source. This “subsource” told them unambiguously that the scandalous claims in the dossier were based on his own statements to Steele but that they were exaggerated and distorted in the dossier. The subsource told the FBI that Steele’s misleading, unverified claims were simply rumors and “bar talk.” Again, the FBI had this damning evidence in hand before it renewed the FISA applications on Carter Page. (It should have had them before the first application, but it didn’t bother.) Again, it lied to the FISA court.

    These are serious crimes, not only against Carter Page but against the true target of the spying, Donald Trump’s campaign and presidency -- and ultimately against the American people. Those who committed the crimes must be held to account. 

    But as far as I know, none of the FBI officials involved in surveilling Trump based upon these lies have yet been prosecuted. 

    Speaking of accountability, I think this article makes some good points regarding Adam Schiff's record:  Adam Schiff's history of inaccuracies, conspiracy theories follows him to Senate floor

    Conservatives take a decidedly different view. They wonder on social media why a congressman who floated unproven conspiracies and a false dossier is leading the case against Mr. Trump, and they ask why the liberal media are so uncritical.

    As a backdrop: On Jan. 10, 2017, BuzzFeed posted the Christopher Steele dossier, which made a dozen felony charges against Mr. Trump and his allies. A month later, The New York Times reported that the intelligence community owned a year’s worth of phone records and intercepts between the Trump campaign and Kremlin intelligence.

    The dossier allegations and Times story were both false.

    The next month, the House Permanent Select Committee on Intelligence convened the first major hearing into Russia’s interference in the 2016 election by computer hacking and social media warfare. A key question was whether the Trump campaign was a witting ally.

    It was in that media glare that Mr. Schiff began making a series of conspiracy claims as he sat on a committee that is supposed to deal in facts. At the witness table were FBI Director James B. Comey and Navy Adm. Michael S. Rogers, head of the electronic-listening National Security Agency.

    Mr. Schiff immediately endorsed the 35-page dossier and praised its author, former British intelligence officer Mr. Steele.

    To bolster Mr. Steele’s credibility, Mr. Schiff said this about Trump campaign adviser Carter Page and Russian oil giant Rosneft: “Is it a coincidence that the Russian gas company Rosneft sold a 19% share after former British intelligence officer Steele was told by Russian sources that Carter Page was offered fees on a deal of just that size?”

    The only coincidence was that the 19% figure was in the press weeks before Mr. Steele wrote his memo.

    Mr. Schiff also quoted Mr. Steele on a purported conspiracy between campaign chairman Paul Manafort and Mr. Page: “According to Steele, it was Manafort who chose Page to serve as a go-between for the Trump campaign and Russian interests.”

    Independent evidence shows the two never knew or spoke with each other.

    Mr. Schiff also said Mr. Steele was “highly regarded” by U.S. intelligence.

    When Mr. Page later appeared before the committee, Mr. Schiff repeatedly quoted the dossier in questioning the former aide, forcing him to disprove what Mr. Steele had written.

    Mr. Schiff also tried to use Mr. Page to prove another dossier allegation: that Trump attorney Michael Cohen secretly traveled to Prague to visit operatives of Russian President Vladimir Putin. He asked Mr. Page whether his 2016 trip to Hungary was linked to Cohen.

    By November 2017, Mr. Schiff was dismissing critics and sticking by Mr. Steele and his dossier.

    “So I think this is a bit of an effort to discredit Christopher Steele, discredit the dossier, ignore how much of it has been corroborated already and ignore the fact that the intelligence community is operating from a broad array of sources as a way of basically calling this all a hoax. And it just doesn’t add up to me,” he said on CNN...

    Mr. Schiff said several times that he had seen evidence of Trump-Russia collusion to interfere in the election and it was beyond circumstantial.

    He began this talking point in March 2017.

    “I can tell you that the case is more than that,” he said on MSNBC. “And I can’t go into the particulars, but there is more than circumstantial evidence now.”

    Special counsel Robert Mueller said in his March 2019 report that he did not find a Trump election conspiracy. No Trump associate was charged in such a conspiracy...

    As the dossier’s credibility began to fall apart in 2017, Rep. Devin Nunes, California Republican and then-chairman of the House intelligence committee, began an attempt to find out who financed Mr. Steele’s work and to answer this question: Did the FBI use the dossier to obtain a judge’s permission to place a Foreign Intelligence Surveillance Act wiretap on Mr. Page?
    Mr. Schiff, who voted to impeach Mr. Trump for not turning over documents, opposed Mr. Nunes on both fronts.

    He fought Mr. Nunes’ bank subpoenas, which forced Democrats to acknowledge in October 2017 that the Hillary Clinton campaign funded the dossier through opposition research firm Fusion GPS and co-founder Glenn R. Simpson.

    After Mr. Nunes issued a memo in 2018 disclosing FISA abuses, Mr. Schiff issued a countermemo that proved off-base on several points.

    Mr. Schiff titled his Jan. 29, 2018, countermemo “Correcting the Record — The Russia Investigation.”

    “FBI and DOJ officials did not ‘abuse’ the Foreign Intelligence Surveillance Act (FISA) process, omit material information, or subvert this vital tool to spy on the Trump campaign,” he said.
    In fact, Justice Department Inspector General Michael E. Horowitz’s Dec. 9 report found that the FBI did abuse FISA. He found 17 instances in which agents submitted inaccurate information to the judge or omitted exculpatory statements about Mr. Page.

    Mr. Horowitz said the warrant could not have been submitted without the Democratic Party-financed dossier. There was no other evidence of a conspiracy.

    Mr. Schiff said in his countermemo: “In subsequent FISA renewals, DOJ provided additional information obtained through multiple independent sources that corroborated Steele’s reporting.”

    Not true, said Mr. Horowitz. None of Mr. Steele’s reporting in the warrant was ever corroborated. In fact, FBI agents acquired evidence from Mr. Steele’s main source, who placed great doubt in Mr. Steele’s allegations. But the FBI left this evidence out of subsequent warrant renewals.

    Mr. Schiff said in his countermemo: “The FBI and, subsequently, the Special Counsel’s investigation into links between the Russian government and Trump campaign associates has been based on troubling law enforcement and intelligence information unrelated to the ‘dossier.’”

    In fact, there is no indication in the Mueller or Horowitz reports that agents found evidence — texts, emails, communication intercepts, informants or whistleblowers — that provided evidence of a conspiracy outside of the dossier.

    Peace, love, and hugs...


    Worldview

     I haven't been posting much here of late because I prefer writing in Google Docs. I've been linking most of my great thoughts into ...